SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 49
Download to read offline
Ad Exchanges, Targeting
        & Optimization

    “From Mad Men to X-Men”


             April 2011
      First Published in September 2009
]
              CONFIDENTIAL
A Word from Gridley & Company, LLC
   Almost every slice of the advertising pie is undergoing major transformation. With new devices,
   channels, technologies, content, and formats, advertising has never been more complex. Ad
   exchanges, ad networks, optimizers, targeting platforms, new forms of data, and the explosion
   of online inventory have forced massive changes in the old ways of Madison Avenue. Today’s
   Don Draper needs to be part Wall Street trader, part technologist, and part media maven – the
   new X-Men. The stakes are high and new technologies are the “change agents”. The interest
   level in the landscape is taking off and has been a huge area for investment and M&A activity in
   2010. We designed this Gridley Industry Overview to help you navigate this new landscape.

   The thinking behind this report began in the spring/summer of 2009 when it seemed to be the
   favorite topic of lots of major media, advertising, and data companies. We did comprehensive
   research, meeting with or talking to most of the leading emerging companies in the sector
   before launching the initial version of this report in the fall of 2009. This report was the first one
   written amongst the investment banking community and we believe served as a basis for future
   reports issued by others.

   We hope you enjoy this comprehensive industry overview and our perspectives. Please give us
   a call to discuss the content of this presentation
                                              Linda Gridley
                                            President & CEO
                                      linda.gridley@gridleyco.com
        Karen Yau Smith                       212-400-9710                         Pratik Patel
          Vice President                                                         Vice President
   karen.smith@gridleyco.com                                              pratik.patel@gridleyco.com
           212-400-9718                                                           212-400-9712

April 2011                                         2
Table of Contents

   I.   Industry Introduction and Overview

   II. The Landscape of Players

   III. The Opportunities

   IV. How Gridley Can Help




April 2011                         3
I. Industry Introduction and Overview




April 2011               4
Introduction
             • Almost every slice of the advertising pie is undergoing major transformation

             • With new devices, channels, technologies, content, and formats, advertising
               has never been more complex

             • Ad exchanges, ad networks, optimizers, targeting platforms, new forms of
               data, and the explosion of online inventory have forced massive changes in
               the old ways of Madison Avenue

             • Today’s Don Draper needs to be part Wall Street trader, part technologist, and
               part media maven – the new X-Men

             • The stakes are high and new technologies are the “change agents”

             • The interest level in the landscape is taking off and
               investment and M&A activity is right around the corner

             • We designed this Gridley Industry Overview to help
               you navigate this new landscape




April 2011                                5
Stakes are High: Making Display Ads Effective
   • Improving economy + re-entry of financial and auto advertisers = almost
     double digit growth in 2010
   • Online display will continue to capture shifting ad spend from large brand
     marketers
                                         U.S. Online Advertising Spending, by Format
               ($ in millions)
                                                                      '09 - '10                                       '10 - '14
                Channel                    2008     2009     2010     Growth      2011     2012     2013     2014      CAGR
                Search                    $10,528 $11,055 $12,823          16.0% $14,747 $16,811 $18,997 $21,276       13.5%
                Display Advertising         7,639   7,485   8,172           9.2%   9,102 10,107 11,141 12,196          10.5%
                Classifieds/Auctions        3,147   2,502   2,176         (13.0%)  2,133   2,154   2,154   2,154       (0.3%)
                Lead Generation/E-mail      2,134   1,790   1,694          (5.4%)  1,745   1,780   1,812   1,830        1.9%
                          Total           $23,448 $22,832 $24,865           8.9% $27,727 $30,852 $34,104 $37,456       10.8%




                % Mix

                Search                      44.9%    48.4%    51.6%                53.2%    54.5%    55.7%    56.8%
                Display Advertising         32.6%    32.8%    32.9%                32.8%    32.8%    32.7%    32.6%
                Classifieds/Auctions        13.4%    11.0%     8.8%                 7.7%     7.0%     6.3%     5.8%
                Lead Generation/E-Mail       9.1%     7.8%     6.8%                 6.3%     5.8%     5.3%     4.9%
                          Total            100.0%   100.0%   100.0%               100.0%   100.0%   100.0%   100.0%




     Source: Barclays Internet Data Book, February 2010

April 2011                                                            6
But Online Display Faces Challenges
 • Too many vendors representing inventory
    – Hundreds of ad networks in all shapes and sizes
    – Horizontal, vertical, display, performance, video, in-game, social apps, and mobile
 • Fragmented audiences
    – Traffic is dispersed across the entire “tail”
 • Lack of transparency in ad networks
    – Advertisers don’t know where and when their ads run
    – Publishers are not guaranteed “blind” inventory
 • No standard KPI’s
    – How do you measure success and attribution? Clicks? Engagements?
 • Little control over pricing
    – Advertisers want to maximize ROI = lower CPM + higher conversion
    – Publishers want to maximize yield = higher CPM + more premium inventory
 • Agencies / buyers are giving away a lot of margin to the ad networks
    – Ad networks are making 30% - 40% margins

April 2011                                       7
New Technologies are Leading the Change
 • Real-time Exchanges offer promise of transparency, market pricing, and liquidity

 • Demand Side Platforms offer the Holdcos and marketers a solution

 • Trading Desks at the agencies are building in-house expertise in optimization

 • Data Management Platforms offer online audience segmentation at a detailed level

 • Ad Creative Optimization allows dynamic ad serving of the right ad to the right
   audience at the right time

 • Social Targeting platforms enable marketers to target based on implicit and
   explicit social information

 • Publishing Yield Optimizers aggregate inventory and maximize CPMs for
   publishers – they look a lot like the exchanges

 • Ad Networks are trying to hold on to their high margins by adding better targeting
   technologies, high value services, and / or going deep into a vertical



April 2011                                8
The New Players are Staking Out Positions
           • New ad targeting, optimization, and data companies are redefining the landscape
                                                       Demand Side – Advertising $$                                  Supply Side - Inventory


                                                                     Ad
                                                                      Ad                                                Direct Sales
                                                                  “Traders”
                                                                  “Traders”                                                Force
 Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers




                                                                                    Demand
                                                                                     Demand
                                          Data Management Tools




                                                                                       Side




                                                                                                                                                                           Data Management & Publisher Tools
                                                                                       Side




                                                                                                                                       Data Measurement & Site Analytics
                                                                                   Optimization
                                                                                   Optimization
                                                                                    Platforms
                                                                                    Platforms
                                                                                                  Ad Exchanges
                                                                                                  Ad Exchanges

                                                                                      Data
                                                                                       Data




                                                                                                                                                                                                               Publishers
                                                                                   Management
                                                                                   Management
                                                                                    Platforms
                                                                                    Platforms


                                                                                                                         Display Ad
                                                                                     Social
                                                                                      Social      Publishing Yield
                                                                                                  Publishing Yield       Networks
                                                                                    Targeting
                                                                                    Targeting       Optimizers
                                                                                                    Optimizers




                                                 Rich Media                   Ad Creative
                                                                              Ad Creative
                                                Ad Platforms                  Optimizers
                                                                              Optimizers


April 2011                                                                                          9
The Emerging Online Advertising Ecosystem
                                                                 Demand Side – Advertising $$                                        Supply Side - Inventory

                                                                                              Demand Side
                                                                                              Optimization                             Direct Sales
                                                                                               Platforms                                  Force
                                                                                                                  Ad Exchanges


                                                                                 Ad
                                         Data Management Tools




                                                                                                                                      Ad Networks
                                                                              “Traders”
 Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers




                                                                                                                                                                                                  Data Management & Publisher Tools
                                                                                                                                              24/7




                                                                                                                                                              Data Measurement & Site Analytics
                                                                                                                                             Acerno
                                                                                                                                           Adconion
                                                                                                                                              Adify
                                                                                                                                             Adroll
                                                                                                                                       Audience Science
                                                                                                                                              Bizo
                                                                                   Data                                                    Brand.net




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Publishers
                                                                               Management                                                  BrightRoll
                                                                                                                                          Burst Media
                                                                                Platforms                                                    Casale
                                                                                                                                        Collective Media
                                                                                                                                           Connexus
                                                                                                                                        CPX Interactive
                                                                                                                                        Epic Advertising
                                                                                                                                    FOX Audience Network
                                                                                                                                          Glam Media
                                                                                                                                      Google Ad Network
                                                                                                                                         Gorilla Nation
                                                                                   Social                                                 InterCLICK
                                                                                  Targeting                                                 Kontera
                                                                                                                                          Lucid Media
                                                                                                                                    Microsoft Media Network
                                                                                                                                           Platform-A
                                                                 Rich Media                                      Publishing Yield
                                                                                                                                         Specific Media
                                                                                                                                         Tremor Media
                                                                 EyeWonder                                         Optimizers            Tribal Fusion
                                                                                                                                            Turn Inc.
                                                                 Mediamind                                                            Undertone Network
                                                                  Pointroll                        Ad Creative                             ValueClick
                                                                   Unicast                         Optimizers                            Vibrant Media
                                                                                                                                     Yahoo Media Network
                                                                  VideoEgg                                                                   Yume



April 2011                                                                                                         10
The Real World is Still Complicated
           • The ecosystem hasn’t rationalized the intermediaries yet – consolidation is coming!
                                                                     Demand Side                                       Supply Side


                                                                     Ad
                                                                      Ad                                             Direct Sales
                                                                  “Traders”
                                                                  “Traders”                                             Force
 Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers




                                                                                    Demand
                                                                                     Demand
                                          Data Management Tools




                                                                                       Side




                                                                                                                                                                        Data Management & Publisher Tools
                                                                                       Side




                                                                                                                                    Data Measurement & Site Analytics
                                                                                   Optimization
                                                                                   Optimization
                                                                                    Platforms
                                                                                    Platforms        The Ad
                                                                                                      The Ad
                                                                                                    Exchanges
                                                                                                    Exchanges
                                                                                      Data
                                                                                       Data




                                                                                                                                                                                                            Publishers
                                                                                   Management
                                                                                   Management
                                                                                    Platforms
                                                                                    Platforms


                                                                                                                     Display Ad
                                                                                     Social
                                                                                      Social      Publishing Yield
                                                                                                  Publishing Yield   Networks
                                                                                    Targeting
                                                                                    Targeting       Optimizers
                                                                                                    Optimizers




                                                 Rich Media                   Ad Creative
                                                                              Ad Creative
                                                Ad Platforms                  Optimizers
                                                                              Optimizers


April 2011                                                                                          11
Capabilities Cross Over Multiple Platforms
   • Most platforms have multiple capabilities across both the demand and sell sides
   • Many are still figuring out their core capabilities or repositioning them
                                                        Pre-Campaign                                                                   Campaign Deployment                                            Post-Campaign
                                                                                                 Creative                                 Exchange & Ad
                               Media Planning                     Audience    Advertiser Data   Dynamic Ad   Optimization &     Data         Network    Publisher Yield Publisher Site Publisher Data   Analytics &
                                  / Buying         Creative       Selection    Management         Serving      Targeting      Enhancing      Buy/Sell    Optimization     Analytics     Management      Reporting

Agencies / Media Buyers / Ad
Traders

Advertiser Data Management

Rich Media Platforms

Dynamic Ad Creative
Optimizers

Demand Side Platforms

Data Management Platforms

Social Targeting


Ad Exchanges

Ad Networks

Publishing Yield Optimizers

Publisher Data Measurement
& Site Analytics

Publisher Data Management


                                                Core Capability
                                                Component of Offering
                                                Some Capability




April 2011                                                                                             12
Key Factors for Success
 • “Industrial-grade” technology platforms that deliver true
   real-time performance at scale

 • Easy-to-use platform interfaces that minimize work flow
   disruptions

 • Ability to provide transparency and “trustability” across
   platform or service offerings

 • Strong “customer” services focus as new marketers and
   suppliers enter market

 • Clear performance measurement and reports that don’t
   require a Ph.D. to understand

 • Ability to draw actionable insights out of reports, activate
   vast stores of data, and implement the “call-to-action”




April 2011                                  13
Relevancy & Sustainability in Ecosystem 2.0
   • Are the “Change Agents” in the new online ecosystem just another set of
     intermediaries?

   • Who is staking out a long-term sustainable position?

   • Do the optimization technologies grow margin or eliminate margin? Where are the
     long-term margins?

   • Which is the better “beachhead”– the publisher side or the advertiser side? Can
     you provide a solution to both?

   • Has the value of the data surpassed the value of an ad unit?

   • Will data become commoditized?

   • Do the new entrants need to be principals in the media not just enabling
     tools/platforms?

   • Will the ecosystem evolve to Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo and then everyone
     else?




April 2011                                 14
Participants at January 2011 Gridley Conference
   • Gridley has stayed in front of this emerging industry and continues to provide
     thought leadership

       PRESENTATIONS                 PANELISTS                  ATTENDEES




April 2011                                15
II. The Landscape of Players




April 2011                16
The Ad Traders are at the Agencies
   • The ad holdcos are actively positioning themselves in the landscape
      – Evaluating all the players but have never been successful at buying
        technology companies
   • Ultimately will stay gate keepers of the media spend and utilize their
     “traders” and technology for execution and analysis
                          Havas                 IPG            MDC Partners       Omnicom Group             Publicis          WPP Group
                                                                Varick Media       Omnicom Media          VivaKi Nerve      Media Innovation
     Trading Unit         Adnetik             Cadreon
                                                                Management          Group Digital            Center           Group / B3

                                                                                         N/A

     Head of Unit Edward Montes         Quentin George       Neeraj Kochhar       Sean Finnegan        Curt Hecht          Brian Lesser
     Description    Digital trading    Custom audience     Media traders using Partnering with Fox     Digital media       Optimizer of ad
                    network and agency trading marketplace algorithms and data Audience Network        optimization agency network spend
                                                           to trade in real-time (FAN) for access to   for premium
                                                                                 audience targeting    inventory
                                                                                 tools

     Technology     DataXu              Multiple platforms   Multiple platforms  FAN's Audience        Private platform   Private platform
     Platform                                                                    Insights, Audience    (Audience on
                                                                                 Planner and Real-     Demand)
                                                                                 Time Bidding          ATOM Systems
                                                                                 platforms             (Razorfish)
     Status         Now operating in    Out of beta and      Established in 2008 Announced October     Test mode in 2008; Went live in middle
                    U.S., no longer     serving clients                          2009                  live clients today of 2008
                    owned by Havas


April 2011                                                              17
Demand Side Optimization Platforms (“DSPs”)
 • New breed of trading technology platforms that combine bid optimization, data integration,
   analytics, and supply relationships to optimize display ad buys
    – “Bloomberg terminals” for the media buyers
 • “Trading desks” provide the execution – Adnetik, Cadreon, Varick Media, VivaKi, and B3
 • Attracting a lot of interest from investors and strategic buyers
                                                                                                                 Capital
                                                      Year                                                       Raised
              Company                               Founded                       Investors                      ($mm)
                              www.adbuyer.com        2007     NA                                                   NA
                              New York, NY
                              www.adchemy.com        2004     Accenture, August Capital, Mayfield Fund           $55.5
                              Redwood City, CA
                              www.appnexus.com       2007     First Round Capital, Khosla Ventures, Kodiak        65.5
                              New York, NY                    Venture Partners, Microsoft, Venrock
                              www.dataxu.com         2007     Atlas Venture LLP, Flybridge Capital Partners,      17.0
                              Cambridge, MA                   Menlo Ventures
                              www.invitemedia.com    2007     First Round Capital; acquired by Google in June      NA
                              Philadelphia, PA                2010
                              www.lucidmedia.com     1999     Intel Capital, Lake Street Capital LLC, MMV         22.4
                              Reston, VA                      Financial Inc., RBC Capital Markets Corporation,
                                                              Redleaf Group Inc.
                              www.mediamath.com      2007     Safeguard Scientifics, QED Investors LLC,           16.6
                              New York, NY                    European Founders Fund
                              www.triggit.com        2006     Bay Partners, DG Incubation, Inc., Foundry           4.7
                              San Francisco, CA               Group, Spark Capital
                              www.turn.com           2005     Focus Ventures, Norwest Venture Partners,           38.5
                              Redwood City, CA                Shasta Ventures, Trident Capital
                              www.xplusone.com       1999     ATV, Bantam Group, Inc., Blue Chip Ventures,        30.8
                              New York, NY                    Echelon Ventures, Hudson Ventures, Seed
                                                              Partners, WS Capital



April 2011                                            18
Data Management Platforms
   • Data management platforms provide cookie data to segment high value audiences
      – Allows media buyers to target only the impressions they want
   • Incorporating data from multiple sources – offline and online
   • Speaking the language of database marketers – data management, audience
     segmentation, new marketing cohorts

                                                                                                                   Capital
                                                     Year                                                          Raised
      Company                                      Founded                       Investors                         ($mm)
                         www.almondnet.com          1998     Argoquest Inc.                                         $1.0
                         New York, NY
                         www.audiencescience.com    2000     Angel Investors L.P., BDO Seidman, LLP, Cedar          89.6
                         Bellevue, WA                        Grove Investments LLC, Clear Fir Partners, L.P.,
                                                             Deutsche Bank, Dot Edu Ventures, Gulf
                                                             International Bank Private Equity, Integral Capital
                                                             Partners, Mayfield Fund, MeriTech Capital
                                                             Partners, Mohr Davidow Ventures, Pacific
                                                             Partners, Second Avenue Partners, Staenberg
                                                             Venture Partners, W Capital Partners

                         www.bizo.com               2008     Ascent Ventures, Bessemer Venture Partners,             6.0
                         San Francisco, CA                   Venrock, Vulcan Capital
                         www.bluekai.com            2007     Battery Ventures, BV Capital Management,               35.1
                         Bellevue, WA                        eVenture Capital Partners, GGV Capital, Pinnacle
                                                             Ventures, Redpoint Ventures, Sequel Venture
                                                             Partners
                         www.brilig.com             2006     NA                                                      NA
                         New York, NY




April 2011                                          19
Data Management Platforms (cont’d)
                                                                                                                      Capital
                                                             Year                                                     Raised
             Company                                       Founded                         Investors                  ($mm)
                       www.crosspixelmedia.com              2010     NA                                                 2.0
                       New York, NY
                       www.datalogix.com                    2002     Advantage Capital Partners, General Catalyst      15.2
                       Westminster, CO                               Partners, Sequel Venture Partners
                       www.demdex.com                       2008     First Round Capital, Genacast Ventures, Shasta     7.0
                       New York, NY                                  Ventures
                       www.exelate.com                      2006     Carmel Ventures, Menlo Ventures                   19.0
                       Petach Tikvah, Israel
                       www.lotame.com                       2006     Battery Ventures, Betaworks, Emergence Capital    25.0
                       Elkridge, MD                                  Partners, Hillcrest Capital Partners
                       www.peer39.com                       2006     Canaan Partners, Dawntreader Ventures,            21.7
                       New York, NY                                  Evergreen Venture Partners, JPMP Capital,
                                                                     Silicon Valley Bank
                       www.buysight.com                     2008     Onset Ventures, Rembrandt Venture Partners        16.0
                       (Formerly known as Permuto, Inc.)
                       Palo Alto, CA
                       www.quantcast.com                    2005     Cisco Systems, Glynn Capital Management,          53.2
                       San Francisco, CA                             Polaris Venture Partners, Inc., Revolution
                                                                     Ventures, The Founders Fund, Western
                                                                     Technology Investment
                       www.targusinfo.com                   1993     TA Associates, Inc.                               60.0
                       Vienna, VA




April 2011                                                  20
Social Targeting
 • Optimizing ads based on social marketing data
    – Identifying the influencers through social connections
    – Did you download a song? How big is your friends network? Did you comment on a
      picture?
 • Activating data based on social graph and engagement

                                                                                                           Capital
                                                 Year                                                      Raised
      Company                                  Founded                      Investors                      ($mm)
                       www.33across.com         2007     First Round Capital, RoseTech Ventures, LLC        $1.3
                       New York, NY

                       www.lotame.com           2006     Battery Ventures, Betaworks, Emergence Capital     25.0
                       Elkridge, MD                      Partners, Hillcrest Capital Partners

                       www.media6degrees.com    2008     Contour Venture Partners, Coriolis Ventures,       11.8
                       New York, NY                      InMedia Management, U.S. Venture Partners,
                                                         Venrock
                       www.seethroo.us          2007     NA                                                  NA
                       Los Angeles, CA

                       www.rapleaf.com          2005     Active Starts, Dace Ventures, Felicis Ventures,     1.2
                       San Francisco, CA                 JAIC America, Inc., Rembrandt Venture Partners,
                                                         SoftTech VC, Inc., The Founders Fund




April 2011                                       21
Ad Creative Optimizers
 • Dynamic ad creative optimizes ads using the best creative assets when the ad is
   served
    – Ability to serve ads in different colors, images, messaging, and lay-out to different
      audiences in real-time and at scale
 • Integrates third party data to determine most effective ad to serve to right audience
   at right time
                                                                                                                     Capital
                                                          Year                                                       Raised
             Company                                    Founded                      Investors                       ($mm)
                           www.adisn.com                 2007     Battery Ventures, MHS Capital Partners; acquired    $2.2
                           Long Beach, CA                         by CrowdGather in June 2010 for $7.8MM


                           www.adroitinteractive.com     2008     Acquired by MediaMath in April 2010                  NA
                           Boston, MA

                           www.aggregateknowledge.com    2005     DAG Ventures, LLC, First Round Capital,             34.2
                           San Mateo, CA                          FLOODGATE, Kleiner, Perkins, Caufield & Byers,
                                                                  NetService Ventures, OVP Venture Partners, Red
                                                                  Rock Ventures, VantagePoint Venture Partners,
                                                                  Western Technology Investment


                           www.dapper.net                2005     Accel Partners, eXeed Technology; acquired by        4.2
                           San Francisco, CA                      Yahoo! in October 2010

                           www.teracent.com              2006     Gold Hill Capital Management, KPG Ventures,          7.8
                           San Mateo, CA                          New Enterprise Associates; acquired by Google in
                                                                  November 2009
                           www.tumri.com                 2004     Accel Partners, Shasta Ventures, Tenaya Capital,    26.5
                           Mountain View, CA                      Time Warner Investments


April 2011                                                22
The Ad Exchanges
 • Ad exchanges are the NASDAQ or NYSE for online ad inventory
 • Provides transparent, dynamic pricing for advertisers
 • Provides liquidity for publishers
 • Big players already own this market




 • Other exchanges are getting in the game




 • Sell-side yield optimizers / inventory aggregators look a lot like the exchanges
 • Today exchanges are for high volume, non-premium inventory
 • In the future, exchanges will list premium inventory too



April 2011                                 23
Publishing Yield Optimizers
 • New platform technologies aggregate publisher inventory and optimize yield on the
   ad networks and exchanges

 • Publishers sell impressions to the highest bidder

 • Publishers can consolidate ad network relationships into a single optimizer

 • Platforms operating in real-time bidding environment look like the exchanges

                                                                                                         Capital
                                                 Year                                                    Raised
       Company                                 Founded                     Investors                     ($mm)
                      www.admeld.com            2007     Foundry Group, Norwest Venture Partners,        $30.0
                      New York, NY                       Spark Capital, Time Warner Investments
                      www.pubmatic.com          2006     Draper Fisher Jurvetson, Helion Venture          14.5
                      Palo Alto, CA                      Partners, Nexus India

                      www.rubiconproject.com    2007     Clearstone Ventures, IDG Ventures, Mayfield      51.0
                      Los Angeles, CA                    Fund, News Corp., Peacock Fund, Stanford, UC
                                                         Berkeley; acquired by Fox Audience Network on
                                                         November 1, 2010




April 2011                                       24
Data Management Tools
 • Massive amounts of data on both the publisher side and advertiser side have
   opened up opportunities for companies to build data solutions

 • Data management tools will help companies warehouse, access, monetize, and
   distribute data efficiently

             Third Party                    Advertiser Data                         Traffic
             Ad Servers                      Management                          Measurement




                           Site Analytics                  Publisher Site Ad
                                                          Servers & Data Tools




April 2011                                       25
III. The Opportunities




April 2011             26
Lots of VC $$ Going into Ad Optimization
                               (Led by)
                  $50MM                    $11MM


                               (Led by)
   (Led by)
                                           $9MM
                  $37MM

                               (Led by)
                                           $8MM
                  $21MM


                                (Led by)

  (Led by)        $15MM                    $6MM




                  $15MM                    $5MM



  Source: CapIQ

April 2011                27
Ongoing Interest in the Sector, But Valuation
    and Fragmentation Remain Issues
   • Continued “interest” in the Ad Optimization & Targeting sector, but little action
     until winners are determined
      – Strategic buyers = looking for new capabilities and/or agency relationships
        • Internet "titans", big media, database and analytics companies, and
          software/diversified technology companies
        • Finding value challenging in the market
      – Private equity investors = looking at consolidation opportunities
        • Solving online display advertising inefficiencies
        • Attractive growth as marketing mix shifts online
   • Media and research analysts have remained interested in the sector
      – Tremendous interest in our "Mad Men to X-Men" report
      – EVERYONE we've talked to is focused on sector
   • Consolidation within sector
      – Few companies with scale, growth and profitability. This will change by end of 2011


April 2011                                     28
Fewer Vendors, More Capabilities
   • Today, many companies offer pieces of the puzzle, but few offer the full suite

      – Marketers and publishers want fewer vendors, which will drive consolidation

   • Consolidators will seek to acquire stand-alone technologies or services to be the
     one-stop shop

      – Look for acquisitions of stand-alone platforms like the DSP’s (Google / Invite Media),
        data management platforms, ad creative optimizers (Yahoo! / Dapper), social targeting
        platforms, and publishing yield optimizers
   • Ad networks should consolidate into a few power groups representing inventory
     and strong media relationships

      – The “Titans” Aren’t Going Anywhere: 24/7, Google Ad Network, Microsoft Media
        Network, Platform A, and Yahoo! Media Network

      – The Consolidators: Adconion, AudienceScience, Collective Media, Connexus, Specific
        Media, and the “Titans”

      – The Targets: Adroll, Bizo, Brand.net, BrightRoll, Gorilla Nation, InterCLICK, Kontera,
        Tremor Media, Turn, Vibrant Media, and Yume
      – The Question Marks: Burst Media, Casale, CPX Interactive, Tribal Fusion, Undertone
        Networks
April 2011                                     29
Who Will Own What?
   • The Ad Holdcos

      – Specialized agencies with their own “trading desks”

      – Traders will trade on the exchanges through multiple primary optimization platforms

      – Will opportunistically acquire specialized technologies and services in online data, data
        analytics, market research, and ad creative technologies

        • However, they are developing best of breed vendor relationships and likely won’t be
          major acquirers in the industry

   • The “Titans”

      – Google, Microsoft, AOL, and Yahoo! will dominate the exchanges and networks

      – Will acquire across entire spectrum of landscape

      – Will compete for inventory listings by offering best execution and liquidity

      – Since all have multiple capabilities across online ad technologies, they will be
        interested in many areas including real-time bidding, data management platforms,
        secondary vertical exchanges, social targeting, yield optimization
April 2011                                      30
Who Will Own What?
   • The Data Companies and Database Marketers

      – Will pursue all data-centric technology platforms across landscape

      – The data management platforms, demand side platforms, and social targeting
        companies will be a priority

      – Database marketers with multi-channel agency services will also look at ad creative
        optimizers and rich media ad serving

   • The Technology Players

      – Look for technology leaders like Adobe, Akamai, Cisco, IBM, and others to make “best-
        in-class” technology platform acquisitions across landscape

      – Some precedents have been set: Adobe / Omniture; Akamai / Acerno; Cisco /
        Tribe.net, Five Across, and Starent

      – New entrants are also getting in on the action: Accenture / Adchemy



April 2011                                    31
Possible Strategic Buyers by Category
                                                       Demand Side – Advertising $$                                                   Supply Side - Inventory

                                                                                      Demand Side
                                                                                      Optimization                   Ad
                                                                     Ad
                                                                      Ad
                                                                                       Platforms                  Exchanges              Direct Sales
                                                                  “Traders”
                                                                  “Traders”                                                                 Force
 Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers




                                                                                          Ad Holdcos
                                                                                           Ad Holdcos
                                          Data Management Tools




                                                                                       Data & Analytics
                                                                                        Data & Analytics
                                                                                            Database




                                                                                                                                                                                            Data Management & Publisher Tools
                                                                                            Database




                                                                                                                                                        Data Measurement & Site Analytics
                                                                                           Marketing
                                                                                            Marketing
                                                                                       Diversified Media
                                                                                       Diversified Media
                                                                                        Internet Titans
                                                                                         Internet Titans
                                                                                          Technology
                                                                                           Technology              Internet Titans
                                                                                                                    Internet Titans
                                                                                                                     Technology
                                                                                                                      Technology
                                                                                          Ad Holdcos
                                                                                           Ad Holdcos
                                                                                       Data & Analytics
                                                                                        Data & Analytics




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Publishers
                                                                     Data                   Database
                                                                                            Database
                                                                                           Marketing
                                                                  Management                Marketing
                                                                                       Diversified Media
                                                                                       Diversified Media
                                                                   Platforms            Internet Titans
                                                                                         Internet Titans
                                                                                          Technology
                                                                                           Technology

                                                                                          Ad Holdcos
                                                                                           Ad Holdcos
                                                                                       Data & Analytics
                                                                                        Data & Analytics
                                                                                                                                         Display Ad
                                                                                                                     Ad Holdcos
                                                                                                                      Ad Holdcos
                                                                                            Database
                                                                                            Database                                     Networks
                                                                    Social                 Marketing
                                                                                            Marketing
                                                                                                                  Diversified Media
                                                                                                                  Diversified Media
                                                                                       Diversified Media           Internet Titans
                                                                                                                    Internet Titans
                                                                   Targeting           Diversified Media             Technology
                                                                                                                      Technology
                                                                                        Internet Titans
                                                                                         Internet Titans
                                                                                          Technology
                                                                                           Technology



                                                                                  Ad Holdcos
                                                                                   Ad Holdcos
                                                                                                                 Publishing Yield
                                                                               Data & Analytics
                                                                                Data & Analytics                   Optimizers
                                                 Rich Media                        Database
                                                                                    Database
                                                                                   Marketing       Ad Creative
                                                Ad Platforms                        Marketing
                                                                               Diversified Media
                                                                               Diversified Media   Optimizers
                                                                                Internet Titans
                                                                                 Internet Titans




April 2011                                                                                                         32
Opportunities by Category
 • Buy-side Optimization Platforms
    – Platforms will power the trading desks of the media trading units
    – Near-term high growth opportunity for arbs
    – Long-term high growth opportunity as more $$$ is deployed on platforms
    – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies,
      database marketers, diversified media, internet titans, technology companies
 • Data Management Platforms
    – Near-term high growth opportunity as enhanced data drives high CPM and arbs can
      leverage spread
    – Long-term high growth opportunity as audience segmentation becomes fundamental
      buying approach
    – Getting high level of interest from all sides
    – Interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies, database
      marketers, diversified media, internet titans, technology companies




April 2011                                      33
Opportunities by Category
 •   Social Targeting
     – Near-term high growth opportunities as marketers seek social marketing buys
     – Companies will either become data providers or agencies
     – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies,
       database marketers, diversified media, internet titans, technology companies
 • Ad Creative Optimizers
     – New breed of ad servers that optimize ad based on variable creative assets
     – Long-term high growth opportunity as marketers adopt creative dynamic ad serving
     – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies,
       database marketers, diversified media, internet titans
 • Ad Exchanges
     – Look for the big, established exchanges to make strategic acquisitions to drive scale
     – Near-term consolidation of niche/vertical exchanges
     – Likely interested buyers: internet titans, technology companies



April 2011                                     34
Opportunities by Category
 • Publishing Yield Optimizers
    – Aggregating publishing inventory and providing yield maximization from bidders
    – Need to pick the right horse
    – Near-term high growth opportunity for first-movers who aggregate high volume inventory
    – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, diversified media, internet titans,
      and technology companies




April 2011                                     35
Select 2010 Acquisitions

                 /                     ~$70MM

    – Google acquires realtime bidding capability for display ads
    – Invite Media’s technology will work within DoubleClick’s display Ad Exchange


                     /                         Amount unknown
    – Technology acquired: MyAds self-service ad-buying platform, FAN’s SDC publisher ad
      server, technology for targeting, and audience analytics and real-time bidding algorithms
      (excluded: FAN’s third-party ad network)
    – Looking to build a platform that offers a portal for automating the buying process, real-
      time bidding, and access to ad exchange (April 2011 launch)


                         /                   ~$55MM
    – Provides Yahoo! the ability to serve dynamic, contextual display ads on its properties




April 2011                                     36
IV. How Gridley Can Help




April 2011              37
Gridley Can Help You…
 • Understand the dynamics of this industry in transition

 • Identify the companies on our market map that best fit your interest areas – we’ve
   met with these companies and know their CEOs
    – We know their strengths, weaknesses, and key market positioning

    – We know their management teams and investors

 • Navigate the Ad Holding Company, Database Marketing, and Data Management
   Platform worlds

 • Identify the financial investors and strategic investors most interested in this
   emerging sector

 • Execute your financial objectives
    – Sell-side Advisory Services

    – Buy-side Advisory Services

    – Private Placement Agent Services

April 2011                                  38
Highly Focused Industry Expertise Underlies
    Our Investment Banking Services
   • Founded in 2001, headquartered in New York, NY

   • Sharp focus provides valuable strategic insights and perspectives for clients
                Advertising &                                            Internet Services
              Marketing Services                                      • Adserving / Online Media Network
                 • Advertising Agencies                               • Customer Acquisition / Affinity Marketing
                 • Customer Care                                      • Content Driven Aggregation
                 • Database Marketing                                 • Contextual Advertising / Search
                 • Loyalty Marketing                                  • Customer / Web Analytics
                 • Market Research                                    • Online Research
                 • Specialty Marketing Services                       • Electronic Payments / Internet Banking
                                                        INFORMATION
                 • Teleservices                                       • EC / Web Integrators
                                                             &
                                                        TECHNOLOGY
                                                             &
                    Database /                            SERVICES    Financial Technology and
               Information Services                                     Outsourcing Services
                • Data Analytics / Decisioning
                                                                        • Payment and Transaction Processing
                • Consumer / Specialty Data Providers
                                                                        • Financial Security
                • Business Data Providers
                                                                        • Financial Technology / Outsourcing
                • Financial Information Services
                                                                        • Business Process Services
                • Specialty Information Providers
                                                                        • IT Consulting / Systems Integration
                • IT Research
                                                                        • IT Outsourcing




April 2011                                                 39
About Gridley
   • Leading boutique Investment Bank specializing in Information Services
     – Comprehensive perspective on Advertising, Marketing, Financial Technology and
       Information Services trends and transactions
   • Strong industry reputation on assignments led by senior bankers
     – Sell-side = Excellent strategic positioning and valuation
     – Buy-side = Deep knowledge and access to emerging companies and industry trends
   • Trusted advisor and strategic matchmaker
     – Thoughtful M&A ideas – not just the logical public company combinations
     – Deliver value to buyers and sellers alike
   • Broad industry network developed over 20+ years
     – Industry leaders, hot emerging growth companies, and senior investors
     – Senior executives on Gridley Advisory Board
   • Well-known thought leader
     – Host of leading Annual Information Services Conference and participant in industry
       events
     – Member of the Interactive Advertising Bureau
     – Highly regarded quarterly newsletter – 2,200+ distribution
     – Sought after commentator and resource for the media

April 2011                                  40
Significant Relevant M&A Experience
  • Gridley has expertise across database marketing and internet services


               Undisclosed                  Undisclosed                          Undisclosed                                Undisclosed                             Undisclosed                       Undisclosed
                                                                                                                                                                     Marketing One to

   Database                                        Sold to
                                                                                                                                                                      One, Inc. d/b/a

                                                                                                                                                                                                               Sold to
                   Acquired by                                                      Acquired by                                Acquired by
   Marketing    MDC Partners Inc.           Parthenon Capital LLC                Schulman, Ronca, &
                                                                                   Bucuvalas, Inc
                                                                                                                       Valassis Communications Inc
                                                                                                                                                                         Acquired by
                                                                                                                                                                 Carlson Marketing Group           Alliance Data Systems, Inc.
                    Advisor                       Advisor                             Advisor                                    Advisor                                 Advisor                            Advisor
                 December 2009                  August 2006                        November 2004                             September 2004                            August 2003                        January 2002




                       Undisclosed                           Undisclosed                              Undisclosed                                    Undisclosed                            Undisclosed


                           Acquired by                           Acquired                                 Acquired                                       Acquired                                  Acquired
                         WPP Group plc                        FetchBack Inc.                          M3 Mobile Marketing                               Pepperjam                            Silverlign Group Inc.

                             Advisor                             Advisor                                   Advisor                                        Advisor                                  Advisor
                           August 2010                          May 2010                                  April 2010                                  September 2009                              April 2009


   Internet
   Services                                                                                                                                                                                 Undisclosed
                        $20,000,000                          Undisclosed                              $157,000,000                                   Undisclosed
                                                                                                                                                     Email Business of                     Ad serving Business of


                           Investment by                         Acquired                                   Acquired                                                                               Sold to
                                                                                                                                                         Sold to
                          TZP Group LLC                       Ward Media, Inc.                            e-Dialog, Inc.                                                                          Aegis plc
                                                                                                                                                One to One Interactive, Inc.
                          Placement Agent                        Advisor                                     Advisor                                     Advisor                                   Advisor
                          December 2008                                                                   January 2008                                  July 2007                                June 2007
                                                                March 2008




April 2011                                                                          41
Leading Annual Industry Conference Showcases Our
    Extensive Network of Relationships
   • Bellwether event focused on our targeted industries
   • Approximately 475 senior-level executives from over 300 companies
        –    Industry leaders, emerging companies, and premier private equity and debt investors
        –    Creates exceptional industry networking and exchange of ideas
   • Differentiated audience and participants vs. other conferences
        –    Audience = senior industry executives, not institutional buy-side investors
        –    Speakers = leading CEOs and executives from top companies:
   • Highly personalized with Gridley arranged “1-on-1”s for clients, presenters, sponsors
   • Presentations by approximately 40 premier private companies and industry panels addressing
     timely topics each year




April 2011                                                   42
Event History – Track Record of Finding
    Successful Companies
   • 188 private companies have presented since 2004

   • Over 50% have completed liquidity transactions




April 2011                               43
Frequent Participation at Industry Events Further Extends
  Our Network and Showcases Our Thought Leadership
                                     Conferences with Gridley Participation
             Mar. 2011   Upstream Seller Forum                  Speaker
                                                                “Making Cents Out of the Display Ecosystem”
             Dec. 2010   Business Insider: IGNITION             Speaker
                                                                “How to Build a $1 Billion Content Business in Three Years or Less”
             Nov. 2010   Digital Hollywood NYC: Media           Moderator
                         Disruption                             - Private Equity and Investor Strategy Panel
                                                                - “The Technology and Entertainment Based Company: From First Round
                                                                to Implementing the Revenue Growth Target Strategy”
             Nov. 2010   ad:tech NYC 2010                       Keynote Speaker
                                                                “Digital: Taking a BIG Bite out of the Big Apple”

             Nov. 2010   Stand Up and Deliver: The              Panelist:
                         Targeting Machine Gets Tested          “I’m With the Brand: Is Ad Net Inventory Ready to Lift the Right Metrics?
             May 2010    TARGUSinfo 2010 Scoring Summit         Speaker:
                                                                “Innovation and Shareholder Value: Why You Need to Take Analytics Real
                                                                Time”
             Mar. 2010   SIIA Digital Media & Software          Speaker:
                         Investment Conference                  “How to Play Your Hand in the M&A Market”
             Feb. 2010   OnMedia NYC 2010                       Panelist:
                                                                “Pricing Private Companies: What’s the 2010 Strategy?”

             Nov. 2009   Audience is King: Targeting the        Panelist:
                         Challenges of 2010                     “Is the Long Tail Wagging? Have the Vertical Networks Lived Up to Their
                                                                Own Hype?”
             Aug. 2009   LeadsCon East                          Panelist:
                                                                “Role of Institutional Advertising in Shaping Internet Advertising”
             July 2009   Ad Network Gold Rush - Boom or         Moderator:
                         Bust?                                  “Are Verticals Standing Up?”



April 2011                                                 44
More than 2,200 Senior Industry Executives Read
  Our Quarterly Newsletter
                                       • Highly respected quarterly newsletter
                                         on industry trends and corporate
                                         finance / M&A activity – The Compass
                                           – Broad, targeted reach: over 2,200 industry
                                             CEO’s and CFO’s, investors, and financial
                                             sponsors

                                           – One of the top investment banking
                                             generated publications in the industry

                                           – Less than 25 opt-out requests since initial
                                             publication in Q1 2003
                                                             The Compass Readership

                                       3,000                                               +23.7%




                                                                                                                      Annual Growth
                                       2,500                                   +26.7%                         2,548
                                                                     +29.3%
                                                                                                    2,350
                                       2,000
                             Readers
                                                            +47.6%
                                                                                         1,900
                                       1,500      +31.0%
                                                                               1,500

                                       1,000                         1,160

                                                           786
                                        500     600

                                          0
                                               2003   2004       2005         2006      2007     2008       7/30/09


April 2011              45
Gridley Often Publishes Strategic Industry
  Overviews and Keynote Presentations that Inform
  Industry Executives & Investors
   • Gridley is well-known for these comprehensive strategic reports and
     presentations that analyze important upcoming trends and investment
     opportunities across our targeted sectors

             Topic                                                                          First Publish Date
             Social Marketing Overview                                                      Coming Soon

             “Billion Dollar Babies: Trends and Opportunities in the E-Commerce Industry”   Coming Soon

             “Making Cents Out of the Display Ecosystem”                                    Mar. 2011
             (Upstream Seller Forum, Speaker)
             “The Virtual Goods Ecosystem”                                                  Dec. 2010
             “How to Build a $1 Billion Content Business in Three Years or Less”            Dec. 2010
             (Business Insider Ignition Conference, Speaker)
             “Digital: Taking a BIG Bite out of the Big Apple”                              Nov. 2010
             (ad:tech New York, Keynote Speaker)
             “Innovation and Shareholder Value: Why You Need to Take Analytics Real Time”   May 2010
             (TARGUSinfo Scoring Summit, Speaker)
             “Mobile Industry Overview: Getting Smart About Smartphones”                    Apr. 2010

             “Ad Exchanges, Targeting, & Optimization: From Mad Men to X-Men”               Sep. 2009

             “The State of Online Marketing”                                                Jun. 2009




Note: Available for download on Gridley’s website, www.gridleyco.com

April 2011                                                       46
The Media Also Seeks Out Our Insights on
  Industry Trends and Transactions




April 2011              47
Selected Recent Gridley Transactions
   • Gridley clients include industry leaders and premier emerging growth companies

   • Gridley provides strategic advisory work in addition to the transactions listed below

              Undisclosed                   Undisclosed                 $20,500,000             Undisclosed                    Undisclosed                        Undisclosed                       Undisclosed




                Acquired by                    Acquired by               Acquired by              Acquired by                      Acquired                           Acquired                       Acquired by
               Oversee.net                TeleTech Holdings         The Dolan Company          WPP Group plc                  FetchBack Inc.                  M3 Mobile Marketing                MDC Partners Inc.
                  Advisor                        Advisor                   Advisor                  Advisor                        Advisor                             Advisor                          Advisor




              Undisclosed                    Undisclosed                $20,000,000                                           $157,000,000                        Undisclosed                       Undisclosed
                                                                                                 $367,000,000




                 Acquired                       Acquired                 Investment by            Acquired by                     Acquired                           Acquired by                      Acquired by
               Pepperjam                 Silverlign Group Inc.         TZP Group LLC        Roper Industries, Inc.              e-Dialog, Inc.                    WPP Group plc                    Quest Software
                  Advisor                        Advisor               Placement Agent              Advisor                        Advisor                             Advisor                         Advisor




              Undisclosed                    Undisclosed                Undisclosed              $113,189,337                   $17,450,000                       Undisclosed                       Undisclosed
             Email Business of                                                                                            PrePay Intelligent Network
                                          Ad serving Business of                                                        Solutions (INS) Business Unit of




                  Sold to                        Sold to                    Sold to             Secondary Offering                Acquired by                       Acquired by                      Acquired by
       One to One Interactive, Inc.             Aegis plc           Parthenon Capital LLC                                          Verisign                   Schulman, Ronca, &              ISIS Equity Partners, Inc.
                  Advisor                                                                                                                                       Bucuvalas, Inc.
                                                 Advisor                    Advisor                Co-Manager              Issued Fairness Opinion                                                     Advisor
                                                                                                                                                                      Advisor




             $138,000,000                    Undisclosed                $58,000,000              Undisclosed                    $55,200,000                        Undisclosed                      Undisclosed
                                                                                            Advisory Communications                                        Marketing One to One, Inc. d/b/a
                                                                                            Systems, Inc. (ACS) d/b/a




                 Acquired                      Acquired by                 Acquired                Acquired by                                                       Acquired by                      Acquired by
                                                                                                                              Follow-On Offering
           Modem Media, Inc.          Valassis Communications Inc      Performics, Inc.          ARAG Group                                                 Carlson Marketing Group           Alliance Data Systems, Inc.
                 Advisor                        Advisor                     Advisor                  Advisor                       Co-Manager                          Advisor                          Advisor




April 2011                                                                                         48
Gridley & Company LLC
             10 East 53rd Street, 24th Floor
                 New York, NY 10022
                   212.400.9720 tel
                   212.400.9717 fax
                  Twitter: @gridleyco
                  www.gridleyco.com




April 2011                 49

More Related Content

What's hot

Blockchain revolution
Blockchain revolutionBlockchain revolution
Blockchain revolutionfahad ali
 
What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...
What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...
What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...Bernard Marr
 
Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business
Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business
Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business Bernard Marr
 
How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps
How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps
How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps Bernard Marr
 
How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?
How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?
How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?Bernard Marr
 
Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage
Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage
Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage Bernard Marr
 
The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...
The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...
The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...Bernard Marr
 
9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...
9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...
9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...Bernard Marr
 
The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020
The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020
The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020Bernard Marr
 
Cognitive business
Cognitive businessCognitive business
Cognitive businessYann Lecourt
 
The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020
The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020
The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020Bernard Marr
 
The Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business Success
The Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business SuccessThe Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business Success
The Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business SuccessBernard Marr
 
14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution
14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution
14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial RevolutionBernard Marr
 
How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...
How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...
How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...Bernard Marr
 
Why Businesses Need Data To Make Better Decisions
Why Businesses Need Data To Make Better DecisionsWhy Businesses Need Data To Make Better Decisions
Why Businesses Need Data To Make Better DecisionsBernard Marr
 
Management of information system survey
Management of information system surveyManagement of information system survey
Management of information system surveyA. K. M. Anwar Hossain
 
How To Get Started With Your AI Journey
How To Get Started With Your AI JourneyHow To Get Started With Your AI Journey
How To Get Started With Your AI JourneyBernard Marr
 
Next-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial Services
Next-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial ServicesNext-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial Services
Next-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial ServicesBernard Marr
 
3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data
3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data
3 Key Ways to Monetize Your DataBernard Marr
 
What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?
What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?
What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?Bernard Marr
 

What's hot (20)

Blockchain revolution
Blockchain revolutionBlockchain revolution
Blockchain revolution
 
What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...
What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...
What Is The Artificial Intelligence Revolution And Why Does It Matter To Your...
 
Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business
Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business
Data Is The New Oil: How Shell Has Become A Data-Driven And AI-Enabled Business
 
How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps
How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps
How To Identify The Best AI Opportunities For Your Business – In 2 Simple Steps
 
How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?
How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?
How To Identify The Data Opportunities For Every Business?
 
Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage
Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage
Managing Data To Drive Competitive Advantage
 
The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...
The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...
The Amazing Ways John Deere Uses Artificial Intelligence And Machine Vision T...
 
9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...
9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...
9 Soft Skills Every Employee Will Need In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence ...
 
The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020
The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020
The 10 Best Data Analytics And BI Platforms And Tools In 2020
 
Cognitive business
Cognitive businessCognitive business
Cognitive business
 
The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020
The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020
The 5 Biggest Technology Trends Disrupting Engineering And Design In 2020
 
The Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business Success
The Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business SuccessThe Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business Success
The Amazing Ways eBay Is Using Artificial Intelligence To Boost Business Success
 
14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution
14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution
14 Essential Leadership Skills During The 4th Industrial Revolution
 
How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...
How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...
How To develop An Artificial Intelligence Strategy: 9 Things Every Business M...
 
Why Businesses Need Data To Make Better Decisions
Why Businesses Need Data To Make Better DecisionsWhy Businesses Need Data To Make Better Decisions
Why Businesses Need Data To Make Better Decisions
 
Management of information system survey
Management of information system surveyManagement of information system survey
Management of information system survey
 
How To Get Started With Your AI Journey
How To Get Started With Your AI JourneyHow To Get Started With Your AI Journey
How To Get Started With Your AI Journey
 
Next-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial Services
Next-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial ServicesNext-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial Services
Next-Generation Cloud Infrastructure for Financial Services
 
3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data
3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data
3 Key Ways to Monetize Your Data
 
What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?
What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?
What Are The Latest Trends in Data Science?
 

Viewers also liked

{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...Daniel Katz
 
Digital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINAL
Digital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINALDigital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINAL
Digital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINALLinda Gridley
 
How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?
How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?
How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?Jane Vita
 
Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2
Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2
Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2Linda Gridley
 
Who’s the best online legal service
Who’s the best online legal service Who’s the best online legal service
Who’s the best online legal service Fit Small Business
 
Analytics Trends 2016: The next evolution
Analytics Trends 2016: The next evolutionAnalytics Trends 2016: The next evolution
Analytics Trends 2016: The next evolutionDeloitte United States
 
The State of Enterprise Software
The State of Enterprise SoftwareThe State of Enterprise Software
The State of Enterprise SoftwareGreylock Partners
 

Viewers also liked (11)

{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
 
Digital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINAL
Digital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINALDigital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINAL
Digital-NY-Press-Release-Q4-2015_FINAL
 
How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?
How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?
How do we see the healthcare's digital future and its impact on our lives?
 
Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2
Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2
Disruption in the Advertising Industry_Final v2
 
The New Moats
The New MoatsThe New Moats
The New Moats
 
Who’s the best online legal service
Who’s the best online legal service Who’s the best online legal service
Who’s the best online legal service
 
Analytics Trends 2016: The next evolution
Analytics Trends 2016: The next evolutionAnalytics Trends 2016: The next evolution
Analytics Trends 2016: The next evolution
 
Saving People Money
Saving People MoneySaving People Money
Saving People Money
 
Healthcare
HealthcareHealthcare
Healthcare
 
The State of Enterprise Software
The State of Enterprise SoftwareThe State of Enterprise Software
The State of Enterprise Software
 
Online Harassment 2017
Online Harassment 2017Online Harassment 2017
Online Harassment 2017
 

Similar to Navigating the Transformation of Online Advertising

1215 omma data dan salmon
1215 omma data dan salmon1215 omma data dan salmon
1215 omma data dan salmonMediaPost
 
Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...
Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...
Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...Shelly Kramer
 
#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners
#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners
#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partnerspropellondon
 
The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?
The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?
The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?SiemerAssoc
 
Ad tech deck 2013 07-22
Ad tech deck 2013 07-22Ad tech deck 2013 07-22
Ad tech deck 2013 07-22MediaPost
 
The Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 Final
The Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 FinalThe Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 Final
The Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 FinalTony Mooney
 
Understand the digital business landscape
Understand the digital business landscapeUnderstand the digital business landscape
Understand the digital business landscapeIgnacio Gil Bárez
 
Customer Experience and Predictive Analytics
Customer Experience and Predictive AnalyticsCustomer Experience and Predictive Analytics
Customer Experience and Predictive AnalyticsRick VARGAS
 
Building Brands Online
Building Brands Online Building Brands Online
Building Brands Online Adheaven.net
 
1011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_1019
1011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_10191011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_1019
1011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_1019Yaakov Kimelfeld, PhD
 
The changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to know
The changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to knowThe changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to know
The changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to knowIABmembership
 
AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016
AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016
AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016Linda Gridley
 
Digital Media: A driver for economic growth
Digital Media: A driver for economic growthDigital Media: A driver for economic growth
Digital Media: A driver for economic growthDelvinia
 
MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022
MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022
MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022Madison Park Group
 
Lead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for Telco
Lead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for TelcoLead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for Telco
Lead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for TelcoSam Thomsett
 
Conversant seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believing
Conversant   seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believingConversant   seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believing
Conversant seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believingJim Nichols
 
Entrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research Business
Entrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research BusinessEntrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research Business
Entrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research BusinessMaRS Discovery District
 

Similar to Navigating the Transformation of Online Advertising (20)

Mad men to x men
Mad men to x menMad men to x men
Mad men to x men
 
Introduction To Peachtree 2009 Final
Introduction To Peachtree 2009 FinalIntroduction To Peachtree 2009 Final
Introduction To Peachtree 2009 Final
 
1215 omma data dan salmon
1215 omma data dan salmon1215 omma data dan salmon
1215 omma data dan salmon
 
Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...
Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...
Integrating Digital Marketing Into Your Business Strategy: 2011 Agriculture M...
 
#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners
#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners
#digi2013 Henry Rowe, FaR Partners
 
The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?
The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?
The Imminent Ad Tech Shakeout: Is Consolidation in the Horizon?
 
Dan chen
Dan chenDan chen
Dan chen
 
Ad tech deck 2013 07-22
Ad tech deck 2013 07-22Ad tech deck 2013 07-22
Ad tech deck 2013 07-22
 
The Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 Final
The Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 FinalThe Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 Final
The Age Of New Reality Marketing V5.1 Final
 
Understand the digital business landscape
Understand the digital business landscapeUnderstand the digital business landscape
Understand the digital business landscape
 
Customer Experience and Predictive Analytics
Customer Experience and Predictive AnalyticsCustomer Experience and Predictive Analytics
Customer Experience and Predictive Analytics
 
Building Brands Online
Building Brands Online Building Brands Online
Building Brands Online
 
1011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_1019
1011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_10191011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_1019
1011BuildingBrandsadagewhitepaper_1019
 
The changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to know
The changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to knowThe changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to know
The changing landscape of display & what smart marketers need to know
 
AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016
AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016
AGC AdTech Industry Update_01.2016
 
Digital Media: A driver for economic growth
Digital Media: A driver for economic growthDigital Media: A driver for economic growth
Digital Media: A driver for economic growth
 
MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022
MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022
MPG MarTech Market Update - June 2022
 
Lead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for Telco
Lead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for TelcoLead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for Telco
Lead to Cash: The Value of Big Data and Analytics for Telco
 
Conversant seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believing
Conversant   seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believingConversant   seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believing
Conversant seven myths that senior marketers need to stop believing
 
Entrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research Business
Entrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research BusinessEntrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research Business
Entrepreneurship 101 - The Market Research Business
 

More from Linda Gridley

AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015
AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015
AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015Linda Gridley
 
In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13
In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13
In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13Linda Gridley
 
Gridley iab Summit Discussion
Gridley iab Summit Discussion Gridley iab Summit Discussion
Gridley iab Summit Discussion Linda Gridley
 
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012Linda Gridley
 
IAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit DiscussionIAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit DiscussionLinda Gridley
 
IAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit DiscussionIAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit DiscussionLinda Gridley
 
Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...
Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...
Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...Linda Gridley
 
2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB
2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB
2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IABLinda Gridley
 
2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC
2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC
2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYCLinda Gridley
 
What Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A Market
What Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A MarketWhat Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A Market
What Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A MarketLinda Gridley
 
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012Linda Gridley
 
State of online marketing april 2011
State of online marketing april 2011State of online marketing april 2011
State of online marketing april 2011Linda Gridley
 
Gridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraise
Gridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraiseGridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraise
Gridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraiseLinda Gridley
 
Gridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-world
Gridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-worldGridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-world
Gridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-worldLinda Gridley
 
POS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping Experience
POS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping ExperiencePOS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping Experience
POS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping ExperienceLinda Gridley
 
Gridley2011 ignitionpresentation
Gridley2011 ignitionpresentationGridley2011 ignitionpresentation
Gridley2011 ignitionpresentationLinda Gridley
 
OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...
OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...
OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...Linda Gridley
 
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY
Gridley's Guide to Digital NYGridley's Guide to Digital NY
Gridley's Guide to Digital NYLinda Gridley
 

More from Linda Gridley (20)

AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015
AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015
AGC-Changing-Consumer-Shopping-Experience-Jan-2015
 
In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13
In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13
In-Store Consumer Experience vFINAL_1.12.13
 
Gridley iab Summit Discussion
Gridley iab Summit Discussion Gridley iab Summit Discussion
Gridley iab Summit Discussion
 
Gridley iab Summit
Gridley iab Summit Gridley iab Summit
Gridley iab Summit
 
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY -- January 2012
 
IAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit DiscussionIAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit Discussion
 
IAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit DiscussionIAB Global Summit Discussion
IAB Global Summit Discussion
 
Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...
Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...
Mobile Goes Mainstreet: Consumers Lead the Way — Key Trends and Investment Op...
 
2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB
2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB
2013 Review of Key Trends In Internet and Digital Media - Presentation at IAB
 
2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC
2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC
2013 Whats Happening In Digital-- Including NYC
 
What Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A Market
What Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A MarketWhat Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A Market
What Buyers Are Thinking & Doing in Today's M&A Market
 
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY November 2012
 
State of online marketing april 2011
State of online marketing april 2011State of online marketing april 2011
State of online marketing april 2011
 
Mobile ecosystem
Mobile ecosystemMobile ecosystem
Mobile ecosystem
 
Gridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraise
Gridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraiseGridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraise
Gridley’s mobile-ny-industy-roadmap-tips-for-successful-fundraise
 
Gridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-world
Gridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-worldGridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-world
Gridley at-business-insider-2012-creating-value-in digital-world
 
POS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping Experience
POS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping ExperiencePOS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping Experience
POS Goes Digital: Evolution of the in Store Shopping Experience
 
Gridley2011 ignitionpresentation
Gridley2011 ignitionpresentationGridley2011 ignitionpresentation
Gridley2011 ignitionpresentation
 
OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...
OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...
OMMA Display 2011 -- Transformation of the Measurement Industry: How Much Can...
 
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY
Gridley's Guide to Digital NYGridley's Guide to Digital NY
Gridley's Guide to Digital NY
 

Recently uploaded

The Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and Cons
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and ConsThe Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and Cons
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and ConsPixlogix Infotech
 
How to write a Business Continuity Plan
How to write a Business Continuity PlanHow to write a Business Continuity Plan
How to write a Business Continuity PlanDatabarracks
 
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platformsDevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platformsSergiu Bodiu
 
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality AssuranceInflectra
 
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxPasskey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
What is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdf
What is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdfWhat is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdf
What is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdfMounikaPolabathina
 
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demoSample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demoHarshalMandlekar2
 
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL RouterScale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL RouterMydbops
 
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdfGenerative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdfIngrid Airi González
 
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance AuditManual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance AuditSkynet Technologies
 
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptxThe State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxUse of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
Emixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native development
Emixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native developmentEmixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native development
Emixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native developmentPim van der Noll
 
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24Mark Goldstein
 
The Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
The Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxThe Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
The Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024BookNet Canada
 
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdfConnecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdfNeo4j
 
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...panagenda
 
Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...
Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...
Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...Farhan Tariq
 
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesHow to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesThousandEyes
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and Cons
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and ConsThe Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and Cons
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing WordPress Pros and Cons
 
How to write a Business Continuity Plan
How to write a Business Continuity PlanHow to write a Business Continuity Plan
How to write a Business Continuity Plan
 
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platformsDevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
DevEX - reference for building teams, processes, and platforms
 
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
 
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxPasskey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Passkey Providers and Enabling Portability: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
What is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdf
What is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdfWhat is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdf
What is DBT - The Ultimate Data Build Tool.pdf
 
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demoSample pptx for embedding into website for demo
Sample pptx for embedding into website for demo
 
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL RouterScale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
 
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdfGenerative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
Generative Artificial Intelligence: How generative AI works.pdf
 
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance AuditManual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
Manual 508 Accessibility Compliance Audit
 
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptxThe State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
The State of Passkeys with FIDO Alliance.pptx
 
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxUse of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
Emixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native development
Emixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native developmentEmixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native development
Emixa Mendix Meetup 11 April 2024 about Mendix Native development
 
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
Arizona Broadband Policy Past, Present, and Future Presentation 3/25/24
 
The Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
The Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxThe Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
The Fit for Passkeys for Employee and Consumer Sign-ins: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024
 
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdfConnecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
 
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
Why device, WIFI, and ISP insights are crucial to supporting remote Microsoft...
 
Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...
Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...
Genislab builds better products and faster go-to-market with Lean project man...
 
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesHow to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
 

Navigating the Transformation of Online Advertising

  • 1. Ad Exchanges, Targeting & Optimization “From Mad Men to X-Men” April 2011 First Published in September 2009 ] CONFIDENTIAL
  • 2. A Word from Gridley & Company, LLC Almost every slice of the advertising pie is undergoing major transformation. With new devices, channels, technologies, content, and formats, advertising has never been more complex. Ad exchanges, ad networks, optimizers, targeting platforms, new forms of data, and the explosion of online inventory have forced massive changes in the old ways of Madison Avenue. Today’s Don Draper needs to be part Wall Street trader, part technologist, and part media maven – the new X-Men. The stakes are high and new technologies are the “change agents”. The interest level in the landscape is taking off and has been a huge area for investment and M&A activity in 2010. We designed this Gridley Industry Overview to help you navigate this new landscape. The thinking behind this report began in the spring/summer of 2009 when it seemed to be the favorite topic of lots of major media, advertising, and data companies. We did comprehensive research, meeting with or talking to most of the leading emerging companies in the sector before launching the initial version of this report in the fall of 2009. This report was the first one written amongst the investment banking community and we believe served as a basis for future reports issued by others. We hope you enjoy this comprehensive industry overview and our perspectives. Please give us a call to discuss the content of this presentation Linda Gridley President & CEO linda.gridley@gridleyco.com Karen Yau Smith 212-400-9710 Pratik Patel Vice President Vice President karen.smith@gridleyco.com pratik.patel@gridleyco.com 212-400-9718 212-400-9712 April 2011 2
  • 3. Table of Contents I. Industry Introduction and Overview II. The Landscape of Players III. The Opportunities IV. How Gridley Can Help April 2011 3
  • 4. I. Industry Introduction and Overview April 2011 4
  • 5. Introduction • Almost every slice of the advertising pie is undergoing major transformation • With new devices, channels, technologies, content, and formats, advertising has never been more complex • Ad exchanges, ad networks, optimizers, targeting platforms, new forms of data, and the explosion of online inventory have forced massive changes in the old ways of Madison Avenue • Today’s Don Draper needs to be part Wall Street trader, part technologist, and part media maven – the new X-Men • The stakes are high and new technologies are the “change agents” • The interest level in the landscape is taking off and investment and M&A activity is right around the corner • We designed this Gridley Industry Overview to help you navigate this new landscape April 2011 5
  • 6. Stakes are High: Making Display Ads Effective • Improving economy + re-entry of financial and auto advertisers = almost double digit growth in 2010 • Online display will continue to capture shifting ad spend from large brand marketers U.S. Online Advertising Spending, by Format ($ in millions) '09 - '10 '10 - '14 Channel 2008 2009 2010 Growth 2011 2012 2013 2014 CAGR Search $10,528 $11,055 $12,823 16.0% $14,747 $16,811 $18,997 $21,276 13.5% Display Advertising 7,639 7,485 8,172 9.2% 9,102 10,107 11,141 12,196 10.5% Classifieds/Auctions 3,147 2,502 2,176 (13.0%) 2,133 2,154 2,154 2,154 (0.3%) Lead Generation/E-mail 2,134 1,790 1,694 (5.4%) 1,745 1,780 1,812 1,830 1.9% Total $23,448 $22,832 $24,865 8.9% $27,727 $30,852 $34,104 $37,456 10.8% % Mix Search 44.9% 48.4% 51.6% 53.2% 54.5% 55.7% 56.8% Display Advertising 32.6% 32.8% 32.9% 32.8% 32.8% 32.7% 32.6% Classifieds/Auctions 13.4% 11.0% 8.8% 7.7% 7.0% 6.3% 5.8% Lead Generation/E-Mail 9.1% 7.8% 6.8% 6.3% 5.8% 5.3% 4.9% Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% Source: Barclays Internet Data Book, February 2010 April 2011 6
  • 7. But Online Display Faces Challenges • Too many vendors representing inventory – Hundreds of ad networks in all shapes and sizes – Horizontal, vertical, display, performance, video, in-game, social apps, and mobile • Fragmented audiences – Traffic is dispersed across the entire “tail” • Lack of transparency in ad networks – Advertisers don’t know where and when their ads run – Publishers are not guaranteed “blind” inventory • No standard KPI’s – How do you measure success and attribution? Clicks? Engagements? • Little control over pricing – Advertisers want to maximize ROI = lower CPM + higher conversion – Publishers want to maximize yield = higher CPM + more premium inventory • Agencies / buyers are giving away a lot of margin to the ad networks – Ad networks are making 30% - 40% margins April 2011 7
  • 8. New Technologies are Leading the Change • Real-time Exchanges offer promise of transparency, market pricing, and liquidity • Demand Side Platforms offer the Holdcos and marketers a solution • Trading Desks at the agencies are building in-house expertise in optimization • Data Management Platforms offer online audience segmentation at a detailed level • Ad Creative Optimization allows dynamic ad serving of the right ad to the right audience at the right time • Social Targeting platforms enable marketers to target based on implicit and explicit social information • Publishing Yield Optimizers aggregate inventory and maximize CPMs for publishers – they look a lot like the exchanges • Ad Networks are trying to hold on to their high margins by adding better targeting technologies, high value services, and / or going deep into a vertical April 2011 8
  • 9. The New Players are Staking Out Positions • New ad targeting, optimization, and data companies are redefining the landscape Demand Side – Advertising $$ Supply Side - Inventory Ad Ad Direct Sales “Traders” “Traders” Force Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers Demand Demand Data Management Tools Side Data Management & Publisher Tools Side Data Measurement & Site Analytics Optimization Optimization Platforms Platforms Ad Exchanges Ad Exchanges Data Data Publishers Management Management Platforms Platforms Display Ad Social Social Publishing Yield Publishing Yield Networks Targeting Targeting Optimizers Optimizers Rich Media Ad Creative Ad Creative Ad Platforms Optimizers Optimizers April 2011 9
  • 10. The Emerging Online Advertising Ecosystem Demand Side – Advertising $$ Supply Side - Inventory Demand Side Optimization Direct Sales Platforms Force Ad Exchanges Ad Data Management Tools Ad Networks “Traders” Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers Data Management & Publisher Tools 24/7 Data Measurement & Site Analytics Acerno Adconion Adify Adroll Audience Science Bizo Data Brand.net Publishers Management BrightRoll Burst Media Platforms Casale Collective Media Connexus CPX Interactive Epic Advertising FOX Audience Network Glam Media Google Ad Network Gorilla Nation Social InterCLICK Targeting Kontera Lucid Media Microsoft Media Network Platform-A Rich Media Publishing Yield Specific Media Tremor Media EyeWonder Optimizers Tribal Fusion Turn Inc. Mediamind Undertone Network Pointroll Ad Creative ValueClick Unicast Optimizers Vibrant Media Yahoo Media Network VideoEgg Yume April 2011 10
  • 11. The Real World is Still Complicated • The ecosystem hasn’t rationalized the intermediaries yet – consolidation is coming! Demand Side Supply Side Ad Ad Direct Sales “Traders” “Traders” Force Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers Demand Demand Data Management Tools Side Data Management & Publisher Tools Side Data Measurement & Site Analytics Optimization Optimization Platforms Platforms The Ad The Ad Exchanges Exchanges Data Data Publishers Management Management Platforms Platforms Display Ad Social Social Publishing Yield Publishing Yield Networks Targeting Targeting Optimizers Optimizers Rich Media Ad Creative Ad Creative Ad Platforms Optimizers Optimizers April 2011 11
  • 12. Capabilities Cross Over Multiple Platforms • Most platforms have multiple capabilities across both the demand and sell sides • Many are still figuring out their core capabilities or repositioning them Pre-Campaign Campaign Deployment Post-Campaign Creative Exchange & Ad Media Planning Audience Advertiser Data Dynamic Ad Optimization & Data Network Publisher Yield Publisher Site Publisher Data Analytics & / Buying Creative Selection Management Serving Targeting Enhancing Buy/Sell Optimization Analytics Management Reporting Agencies / Media Buyers / Ad Traders Advertiser Data Management Rich Media Platforms Dynamic Ad Creative Optimizers Demand Side Platforms Data Management Platforms Social Targeting Ad Exchanges Ad Networks Publishing Yield Optimizers Publisher Data Measurement & Site Analytics Publisher Data Management Core Capability Component of Offering Some Capability April 2011 12
  • 13. Key Factors for Success • “Industrial-grade” technology platforms that deliver true real-time performance at scale • Easy-to-use platform interfaces that minimize work flow disruptions • Ability to provide transparency and “trustability” across platform or service offerings • Strong “customer” services focus as new marketers and suppliers enter market • Clear performance measurement and reports that don’t require a Ph.D. to understand • Ability to draw actionable insights out of reports, activate vast stores of data, and implement the “call-to-action” April 2011 13
  • 14. Relevancy & Sustainability in Ecosystem 2.0 • Are the “Change Agents” in the new online ecosystem just another set of intermediaries? • Who is staking out a long-term sustainable position? • Do the optimization technologies grow margin or eliminate margin? Where are the long-term margins? • Which is the better “beachhead”– the publisher side or the advertiser side? Can you provide a solution to both? • Has the value of the data surpassed the value of an ad unit? • Will data become commoditized? • Do the new entrants need to be principals in the media not just enabling tools/platforms? • Will the ecosystem evolve to Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo and then everyone else? April 2011 14
  • 15. Participants at January 2011 Gridley Conference • Gridley has stayed in front of this emerging industry and continues to provide thought leadership PRESENTATIONS PANELISTS ATTENDEES April 2011 15
  • 16. II. The Landscape of Players April 2011 16
  • 17. The Ad Traders are at the Agencies • The ad holdcos are actively positioning themselves in the landscape – Evaluating all the players but have never been successful at buying technology companies • Ultimately will stay gate keepers of the media spend and utilize their “traders” and technology for execution and analysis Havas IPG MDC Partners Omnicom Group Publicis WPP Group Varick Media Omnicom Media VivaKi Nerve Media Innovation Trading Unit Adnetik Cadreon Management Group Digital Center Group / B3 N/A Head of Unit Edward Montes Quentin George Neeraj Kochhar Sean Finnegan Curt Hecht Brian Lesser Description Digital trading Custom audience Media traders using Partnering with Fox Digital media Optimizer of ad network and agency trading marketplace algorithms and data Audience Network optimization agency network spend to trade in real-time (FAN) for access to for premium audience targeting inventory tools Technology DataXu Multiple platforms Multiple platforms FAN's Audience Private platform Private platform Platform Insights, Audience (Audience on Planner and Real- Demand) Time Bidding ATOM Systems platforms (Razorfish) Status Now operating in Out of beta and Established in 2008 Announced October Test mode in 2008; Went live in middle U.S., no longer serving clients 2009 live clients today of 2008 owned by Havas April 2011 17
  • 18. Demand Side Optimization Platforms (“DSPs”) • New breed of trading technology platforms that combine bid optimization, data integration, analytics, and supply relationships to optimize display ad buys – “Bloomberg terminals” for the media buyers • “Trading desks” provide the execution – Adnetik, Cadreon, Varick Media, VivaKi, and B3 • Attracting a lot of interest from investors and strategic buyers Capital Year Raised Company Founded Investors ($mm) www.adbuyer.com 2007 NA NA New York, NY www.adchemy.com 2004 Accenture, August Capital, Mayfield Fund $55.5 Redwood City, CA www.appnexus.com 2007 First Round Capital, Khosla Ventures, Kodiak 65.5 New York, NY Venture Partners, Microsoft, Venrock www.dataxu.com 2007 Atlas Venture LLP, Flybridge Capital Partners, 17.0 Cambridge, MA Menlo Ventures www.invitemedia.com 2007 First Round Capital; acquired by Google in June NA Philadelphia, PA 2010 www.lucidmedia.com 1999 Intel Capital, Lake Street Capital LLC, MMV 22.4 Reston, VA Financial Inc., RBC Capital Markets Corporation, Redleaf Group Inc. www.mediamath.com 2007 Safeguard Scientifics, QED Investors LLC, 16.6 New York, NY European Founders Fund www.triggit.com 2006 Bay Partners, DG Incubation, Inc., Foundry 4.7 San Francisco, CA Group, Spark Capital www.turn.com 2005 Focus Ventures, Norwest Venture Partners, 38.5 Redwood City, CA Shasta Ventures, Trident Capital www.xplusone.com 1999 ATV, Bantam Group, Inc., Blue Chip Ventures, 30.8 New York, NY Echelon Ventures, Hudson Ventures, Seed Partners, WS Capital April 2011 18
  • 19. Data Management Platforms • Data management platforms provide cookie data to segment high value audiences – Allows media buyers to target only the impressions they want • Incorporating data from multiple sources – offline and online • Speaking the language of database marketers – data management, audience segmentation, new marketing cohorts Capital Year Raised Company Founded Investors ($mm) www.almondnet.com 1998 Argoquest Inc. $1.0 New York, NY www.audiencescience.com 2000 Angel Investors L.P., BDO Seidman, LLP, Cedar 89.6 Bellevue, WA Grove Investments LLC, Clear Fir Partners, L.P., Deutsche Bank, Dot Edu Ventures, Gulf International Bank Private Equity, Integral Capital Partners, Mayfield Fund, MeriTech Capital Partners, Mohr Davidow Ventures, Pacific Partners, Second Avenue Partners, Staenberg Venture Partners, W Capital Partners www.bizo.com 2008 Ascent Ventures, Bessemer Venture Partners, 6.0 San Francisco, CA Venrock, Vulcan Capital www.bluekai.com 2007 Battery Ventures, BV Capital Management, 35.1 Bellevue, WA eVenture Capital Partners, GGV Capital, Pinnacle Ventures, Redpoint Ventures, Sequel Venture Partners www.brilig.com 2006 NA NA New York, NY April 2011 19
  • 20. Data Management Platforms (cont’d) Capital Year Raised Company Founded Investors ($mm) www.crosspixelmedia.com 2010 NA 2.0 New York, NY www.datalogix.com 2002 Advantage Capital Partners, General Catalyst 15.2 Westminster, CO Partners, Sequel Venture Partners www.demdex.com 2008 First Round Capital, Genacast Ventures, Shasta 7.0 New York, NY Ventures www.exelate.com 2006 Carmel Ventures, Menlo Ventures 19.0 Petach Tikvah, Israel www.lotame.com 2006 Battery Ventures, Betaworks, Emergence Capital 25.0 Elkridge, MD Partners, Hillcrest Capital Partners www.peer39.com 2006 Canaan Partners, Dawntreader Ventures, 21.7 New York, NY Evergreen Venture Partners, JPMP Capital, Silicon Valley Bank www.buysight.com 2008 Onset Ventures, Rembrandt Venture Partners 16.0 (Formerly known as Permuto, Inc.) Palo Alto, CA www.quantcast.com 2005 Cisco Systems, Glynn Capital Management, 53.2 San Francisco, CA Polaris Venture Partners, Inc., Revolution Ventures, The Founders Fund, Western Technology Investment www.targusinfo.com 1993 TA Associates, Inc. 60.0 Vienna, VA April 2011 20
  • 21. Social Targeting • Optimizing ads based on social marketing data – Identifying the influencers through social connections – Did you download a song? How big is your friends network? Did you comment on a picture? • Activating data based on social graph and engagement Capital Year Raised Company Founded Investors ($mm) www.33across.com 2007 First Round Capital, RoseTech Ventures, LLC $1.3 New York, NY www.lotame.com 2006 Battery Ventures, Betaworks, Emergence Capital 25.0 Elkridge, MD Partners, Hillcrest Capital Partners www.media6degrees.com 2008 Contour Venture Partners, Coriolis Ventures, 11.8 New York, NY InMedia Management, U.S. Venture Partners, Venrock www.seethroo.us 2007 NA NA Los Angeles, CA www.rapleaf.com 2005 Active Starts, Dace Ventures, Felicis Ventures, 1.2 San Francisco, CA JAIC America, Inc., Rembrandt Venture Partners, SoftTech VC, Inc., The Founders Fund April 2011 21
  • 22. Ad Creative Optimizers • Dynamic ad creative optimizes ads using the best creative assets when the ad is served – Ability to serve ads in different colors, images, messaging, and lay-out to different audiences in real-time and at scale • Integrates third party data to determine most effective ad to serve to right audience at right time Capital Year Raised Company Founded Investors ($mm) www.adisn.com 2007 Battery Ventures, MHS Capital Partners; acquired $2.2 Long Beach, CA by CrowdGather in June 2010 for $7.8MM www.adroitinteractive.com 2008 Acquired by MediaMath in April 2010 NA Boston, MA www.aggregateknowledge.com 2005 DAG Ventures, LLC, First Round Capital, 34.2 San Mateo, CA FLOODGATE, Kleiner, Perkins, Caufield & Byers, NetService Ventures, OVP Venture Partners, Red Rock Ventures, VantagePoint Venture Partners, Western Technology Investment www.dapper.net 2005 Accel Partners, eXeed Technology; acquired by 4.2 San Francisco, CA Yahoo! in October 2010 www.teracent.com 2006 Gold Hill Capital Management, KPG Ventures, 7.8 San Mateo, CA New Enterprise Associates; acquired by Google in November 2009 www.tumri.com 2004 Accel Partners, Shasta Ventures, Tenaya Capital, 26.5 Mountain View, CA Time Warner Investments April 2011 22
  • 23. The Ad Exchanges • Ad exchanges are the NASDAQ or NYSE for online ad inventory • Provides transparent, dynamic pricing for advertisers • Provides liquidity for publishers • Big players already own this market • Other exchanges are getting in the game • Sell-side yield optimizers / inventory aggregators look a lot like the exchanges • Today exchanges are for high volume, non-premium inventory • In the future, exchanges will list premium inventory too April 2011 23
  • 24. Publishing Yield Optimizers • New platform technologies aggregate publisher inventory and optimize yield on the ad networks and exchanges • Publishers sell impressions to the highest bidder • Publishers can consolidate ad network relationships into a single optimizer • Platforms operating in real-time bidding environment look like the exchanges Capital Year Raised Company Founded Investors ($mm) www.admeld.com 2007 Foundry Group, Norwest Venture Partners, $30.0 New York, NY Spark Capital, Time Warner Investments www.pubmatic.com 2006 Draper Fisher Jurvetson, Helion Venture 14.5 Palo Alto, CA Partners, Nexus India www.rubiconproject.com 2007 Clearstone Ventures, IDG Ventures, Mayfield 51.0 Los Angeles, CA Fund, News Corp., Peacock Fund, Stanford, UC Berkeley; acquired by Fox Audience Network on November 1, 2010 April 2011 24
  • 25. Data Management Tools • Massive amounts of data on both the publisher side and advertiser side have opened up opportunities for companies to build data solutions • Data management tools will help companies warehouse, access, monetize, and distribute data efficiently Third Party Advertiser Data Traffic Ad Servers Management Measurement Site Analytics Publisher Site Ad Servers & Data Tools April 2011 25
  • 27. Lots of VC $$ Going into Ad Optimization (Led by) $50MM $11MM (Led by) (Led by) $9MM $37MM (Led by) $8MM $21MM (Led by) (Led by) $15MM $6MM $15MM $5MM Source: CapIQ April 2011 27
  • 28. Ongoing Interest in the Sector, But Valuation and Fragmentation Remain Issues • Continued “interest” in the Ad Optimization & Targeting sector, but little action until winners are determined – Strategic buyers = looking for new capabilities and/or agency relationships • Internet "titans", big media, database and analytics companies, and software/diversified technology companies • Finding value challenging in the market – Private equity investors = looking at consolidation opportunities • Solving online display advertising inefficiencies • Attractive growth as marketing mix shifts online • Media and research analysts have remained interested in the sector – Tremendous interest in our "Mad Men to X-Men" report – EVERYONE we've talked to is focused on sector • Consolidation within sector – Few companies with scale, growth and profitability. This will change by end of 2011 April 2011 28
  • 29. Fewer Vendors, More Capabilities • Today, many companies offer pieces of the puzzle, but few offer the full suite – Marketers and publishers want fewer vendors, which will drive consolidation • Consolidators will seek to acquire stand-alone technologies or services to be the one-stop shop – Look for acquisitions of stand-alone platforms like the DSP’s (Google / Invite Media), data management platforms, ad creative optimizers (Yahoo! / Dapper), social targeting platforms, and publishing yield optimizers • Ad networks should consolidate into a few power groups representing inventory and strong media relationships – The “Titans” Aren’t Going Anywhere: 24/7, Google Ad Network, Microsoft Media Network, Platform A, and Yahoo! Media Network – The Consolidators: Adconion, AudienceScience, Collective Media, Connexus, Specific Media, and the “Titans” – The Targets: Adroll, Bizo, Brand.net, BrightRoll, Gorilla Nation, InterCLICK, Kontera, Tremor Media, Turn, Vibrant Media, and Yume – The Question Marks: Burst Media, Casale, CPX Interactive, Tribal Fusion, Undertone Networks April 2011 29
  • 30. Who Will Own What? • The Ad Holdcos – Specialized agencies with their own “trading desks” – Traders will trade on the exchanges through multiple primary optimization platforms – Will opportunistically acquire specialized technologies and services in online data, data analytics, market research, and ad creative technologies • However, they are developing best of breed vendor relationships and likely won’t be major acquirers in the industry • The “Titans” – Google, Microsoft, AOL, and Yahoo! will dominate the exchanges and networks – Will acquire across entire spectrum of landscape – Will compete for inventory listings by offering best execution and liquidity – Since all have multiple capabilities across online ad technologies, they will be interested in many areas including real-time bidding, data management platforms, secondary vertical exchanges, social targeting, yield optimization April 2011 30
  • 31. Who Will Own What? • The Data Companies and Database Marketers – Will pursue all data-centric technology platforms across landscape – The data management platforms, demand side platforms, and social targeting companies will be a priority – Database marketers with multi-channel agency services will also look at ad creative optimizers and rich media ad serving • The Technology Players – Look for technology leaders like Adobe, Akamai, Cisco, IBM, and others to make “best- in-class” technology platform acquisitions across landscape – Some precedents have been set: Adobe / Omniture; Akamai / Acerno; Cisco / Tribe.net, Five Across, and Starent – New entrants are also getting in on the action: Accenture / Adchemy April 2011 31
  • 32. Possible Strategic Buyers by Category Demand Side – Advertising $$ Supply Side - Inventory Demand Side Optimization Ad Ad Ad Platforms Exchanges Direct Sales “Traders” “Traders” Force Advertisers / Agencies / Media Buyers Ad Holdcos Ad Holdcos Data Management Tools Data & Analytics Data & Analytics Database Data Management & Publisher Tools Database Data Measurement & Site Analytics Marketing Marketing Diversified Media Diversified Media Internet Titans Internet Titans Technology Technology Internet Titans Internet Titans Technology Technology Ad Holdcos Ad Holdcos Data & Analytics Data & Analytics Publishers Data Database Database Marketing Management Marketing Diversified Media Diversified Media Platforms Internet Titans Internet Titans Technology Technology Ad Holdcos Ad Holdcos Data & Analytics Data & Analytics Display Ad Ad Holdcos Ad Holdcos Database Database Networks Social Marketing Marketing Diversified Media Diversified Media Diversified Media Internet Titans Internet Titans Targeting Diversified Media Technology Technology Internet Titans Internet Titans Technology Technology Ad Holdcos Ad Holdcos Publishing Yield Data & Analytics Data & Analytics Optimizers Rich Media Database Database Marketing Ad Creative Ad Platforms Marketing Diversified Media Diversified Media Optimizers Internet Titans Internet Titans April 2011 32
  • 33. Opportunities by Category • Buy-side Optimization Platforms – Platforms will power the trading desks of the media trading units – Near-term high growth opportunity for arbs – Long-term high growth opportunity as more $$$ is deployed on platforms – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies, database marketers, diversified media, internet titans, technology companies • Data Management Platforms – Near-term high growth opportunity as enhanced data drives high CPM and arbs can leverage spread – Long-term high growth opportunity as audience segmentation becomes fundamental buying approach – Getting high level of interest from all sides – Interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies, database marketers, diversified media, internet titans, technology companies April 2011 33
  • 34. Opportunities by Category • Social Targeting – Near-term high growth opportunities as marketers seek social marketing buys – Companies will either become data providers or agencies – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies, database marketers, diversified media, internet titans, technology companies • Ad Creative Optimizers – New breed of ad servers that optimize ad based on variable creative assets – Long-term high growth opportunity as marketers adopt creative dynamic ad serving – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, data & analytics companies, database marketers, diversified media, internet titans • Ad Exchanges – Look for the big, established exchanges to make strategic acquisitions to drive scale – Near-term consolidation of niche/vertical exchanges – Likely interested buyers: internet titans, technology companies April 2011 34
  • 35. Opportunities by Category • Publishing Yield Optimizers – Aggregating publishing inventory and providing yield maximization from bidders – Need to pick the right horse – Near-term high growth opportunity for first-movers who aggregate high volume inventory – Likely interested buyers: technology-centric agencies, diversified media, internet titans, and technology companies April 2011 35
  • 36. Select 2010 Acquisitions / ~$70MM – Google acquires realtime bidding capability for display ads – Invite Media’s technology will work within DoubleClick’s display Ad Exchange / Amount unknown – Technology acquired: MyAds self-service ad-buying platform, FAN’s SDC publisher ad server, technology for targeting, and audience analytics and real-time bidding algorithms (excluded: FAN’s third-party ad network) – Looking to build a platform that offers a portal for automating the buying process, real- time bidding, and access to ad exchange (April 2011 launch) / ~$55MM – Provides Yahoo! the ability to serve dynamic, contextual display ads on its properties April 2011 36
  • 37. IV. How Gridley Can Help April 2011 37
  • 38. Gridley Can Help You… • Understand the dynamics of this industry in transition • Identify the companies on our market map that best fit your interest areas – we’ve met with these companies and know their CEOs – We know their strengths, weaknesses, and key market positioning – We know their management teams and investors • Navigate the Ad Holding Company, Database Marketing, and Data Management Platform worlds • Identify the financial investors and strategic investors most interested in this emerging sector • Execute your financial objectives – Sell-side Advisory Services – Buy-side Advisory Services – Private Placement Agent Services April 2011 38
  • 39. Highly Focused Industry Expertise Underlies Our Investment Banking Services • Founded in 2001, headquartered in New York, NY • Sharp focus provides valuable strategic insights and perspectives for clients Advertising & Internet Services Marketing Services • Adserving / Online Media Network • Advertising Agencies • Customer Acquisition / Affinity Marketing • Customer Care • Content Driven Aggregation • Database Marketing • Contextual Advertising / Search • Loyalty Marketing • Customer / Web Analytics • Market Research • Online Research • Specialty Marketing Services • Electronic Payments / Internet Banking INFORMATION • Teleservices • EC / Web Integrators & TECHNOLOGY & Database / SERVICES Financial Technology and Information Services Outsourcing Services • Data Analytics / Decisioning • Payment and Transaction Processing • Consumer / Specialty Data Providers • Financial Security • Business Data Providers • Financial Technology / Outsourcing • Financial Information Services • Business Process Services • Specialty Information Providers • IT Consulting / Systems Integration • IT Research • IT Outsourcing April 2011 39
  • 40. About Gridley • Leading boutique Investment Bank specializing in Information Services – Comprehensive perspective on Advertising, Marketing, Financial Technology and Information Services trends and transactions • Strong industry reputation on assignments led by senior bankers – Sell-side = Excellent strategic positioning and valuation – Buy-side = Deep knowledge and access to emerging companies and industry trends • Trusted advisor and strategic matchmaker – Thoughtful M&A ideas – not just the logical public company combinations – Deliver value to buyers and sellers alike • Broad industry network developed over 20+ years – Industry leaders, hot emerging growth companies, and senior investors – Senior executives on Gridley Advisory Board • Well-known thought leader – Host of leading Annual Information Services Conference and participant in industry events – Member of the Interactive Advertising Bureau – Highly regarded quarterly newsletter – 2,200+ distribution – Sought after commentator and resource for the media April 2011 40
  • 41. Significant Relevant M&A Experience • Gridley has expertise across database marketing and internet services Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Marketing One to Database Sold to One, Inc. d/b/a Sold to Acquired by Acquired by Acquired by Marketing MDC Partners Inc. Parthenon Capital LLC Schulman, Ronca, & Bucuvalas, Inc Valassis Communications Inc Acquired by Carlson Marketing Group Alliance Data Systems, Inc. Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor December 2009 August 2006 November 2004 September 2004 August 2003 January 2002 Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Acquired by Acquired Acquired Acquired Acquired WPP Group plc FetchBack Inc. M3 Mobile Marketing Pepperjam Silverlign Group Inc. Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor August 2010 May 2010 April 2010 September 2009 April 2009 Internet Services Undisclosed $20,000,000 Undisclosed $157,000,000 Undisclosed Email Business of Ad serving Business of Investment by Acquired Acquired Sold to Sold to TZP Group LLC Ward Media, Inc. e-Dialog, Inc. Aegis plc One to One Interactive, Inc. Placement Agent Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor December 2008 January 2008 July 2007 June 2007 March 2008 April 2011 41
  • 42. Leading Annual Industry Conference Showcases Our Extensive Network of Relationships • Bellwether event focused on our targeted industries • Approximately 475 senior-level executives from over 300 companies – Industry leaders, emerging companies, and premier private equity and debt investors – Creates exceptional industry networking and exchange of ideas • Differentiated audience and participants vs. other conferences – Audience = senior industry executives, not institutional buy-side investors – Speakers = leading CEOs and executives from top companies: • Highly personalized with Gridley arranged “1-on-1”s for clients, presenters, sponsors • Presentations by approximately 40 premier private companies and industry panels addressing timely topics each year April 2011 42
  • 43. Event History – Track Record of Finding Successful Companies • 188 private companies have presented since 2004 • Over 50% have completed liquidity transactions April 2011 43
  • 44. Frequent Participation at Industry Events Further Extends Our Network and Showcases Our Thought Leadership Conferences with Gridley Participation Mar. 2011 Upstream Seller Forum Speaker “Making Cents Out of the Display Ecosystem” Dec. 2010 Business Insider: IGNITION Speaker “How to Build a $1 Billion Content Business in Three Years or Less” Nov. 2010 Digital Hollywood NYC: Media Moderator Disruption - Private Equity and Investor Strategy Panel - “The Technology and Entertainment Based Company: From First Round to Implementing the Revenue Growth Target Strategy” Nov. 2010 ad:tech NYC 2010 Keynote Speaker “Digital: Taking a BIG Bite out of the Big Apple” Nov. 2010 Stand Up and Deliver: The Panelist: Targeting Machine Gets Tested “I’m With the Brand: Is Ad Net Inventory Ready to Lift the Right Metrics? May 2010 TARGUSinfo 2010 Scoring Summit Speaker: “Innovation and Shareholder Value: Why You Need to Take Analytics Real Time” Mar. 2010 SIIA Digital Media & Software Speaker: Investment Conference “How to Play Your Hand in the M&A Market” Feb. 2010 OnMedia NYC 2010 Panelist: “Pricing Private Companies: What’s the 2010 Strategy?” Nov. 2009 Audience is King: Targeting the Panelist: Challenges of 2010 “Is the Long Tail Wagging? Have the Vertical Networks Lived Up to Their Own Hype?” Aug. 2009 LeadsCon East Panelist: “Role of Institutional Advertising in Shaping Internet Advertising” July 2009 Ad Network Gold Rush - Boom or Moderator: Bust? “Are Verticals Standing Up?” April 2011 44
  • 45. More than 2,200 Senior Industry Executives Read Our Quarterly Newsletter • Highly respected quarterly newsletter on industry trends and corporate finance / M&A activity – The Compass – Broad, targeted reach: over 2,200 industry CEO’s and CFO’s, investors, and financial sponsors – One of the top investment banking generated publications in the industry – Less than 25 opt-out requests since initial publication in Q1 2003 The Compass Readership 3,000 +23.7% Annual Growth 2,500 +26.7% 2,548 +29.3% 2,350 2,000 Readers +47.6% 1,900 1,500 +31.0% 1,500 1,000 1,160 786 500 600 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 7/30/09 April 2011 45
  • 46. Gridley Often Publishes Strategic Industry Overviews and Keynote Presentations that Inform Industry Executives & Investors • Gridley is well-known for these comprehensive strategic reports and presentations that analyze important upcoming trends and investment opportunities across our targeted sectors Topic First Publish Date Social Marketing Overview Coming Soon “Billion Dollar Babies: Trends and Opportunities in the E-Commerce Industry” Coming Soon “Making Cents Out of the Display Ecosystem” Mar. 2011 (Upstream Seller Forum, Speaker) “The Virtual Goods Ecosystem” Dec. 2010 “How to Build a $1 Billion Content Business in Three Years or Less” Dec. 2010 (Business Insider Ignition Conference, Speaker) “Digital: Taking a BIG Bite out of the Big Apple” Nov. 2010 (ad:tech New York, Keynote Speaker) “Innovation and Shareholder Value: Why You Need to Take Analytics Real Time” May 2010 (TARGUSinfo Scoring Summit, Speaker) “Mobile Industry Overview: Getting Smart About Smartphones” Apr. 2010 “Ad Exchanges, Targeting, & Optimization: From Mad Men to X-Men” Sep. 2009 “The State of Online Marketing” Jun. 2009 Note: Available for download on Gridley’s website, www.gridleyco.com April 2011 46
  • 47. The Media Also Seeks Out Our Insights on Industry Trends and Transactions April 2011 47
  • 48. Selected Recent Gridley Transactions • Gridley clients include industry leaders and premier emerging growth companies • Gridley provides strategic advisory work in addition to the transactions listed below Undisclosed Undisclosed $20,500,000 Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed Acquired by Acquired by Acquired by Acquired by Acquired Acquired Acquired by Oversee.net TeleTech Holdings The Dolan Company WPP Group plc FetchBack Inc. M3 Mobile Marketing MDC Partners Inc. Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Undisclosed Undisclosed $20,000,000 $157,000,000 Undisclosed Undisclosed $367,000,000 Acquired Acquired Investment by Acquired by Acquired Acquired by Acquired by Pepperjam Silverlign Group Inc. TZP Group LLC Roper Industries, Inc. e-Dialog, Inc. WPP Group plc Quest Software Advisor Advisor Placement Agent Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Undisclosed Undisclosed Undisclosed $113,189,337 $17,450,000 Undisclosed Undisclosed Email Business of PrePay Intelligent Network Ad serving Business of Solutions (INS) Business Unit of Sold to Sold to Sold to Secondary Offering Acquired by Acquired by Acquired by One to One Interactive, Inc. Aegis plc Parthenon Capital LLC Verisign Schulman, Ronca, & ISIS Equity Partners, Inc. Advisor Bucuvalas, Inc. Advisor Advisor Co-Manager Issued Fairness Opinion Advisor Advisor $138,000,000 Undisclosed $58,000,000 Undisclosed $55,200,000 Undisclosed Undisclosed Advisory Communications Marketing One to One, Inc. d/b/a Systems, Inc. (ACS) d/b/a Acquired Acquired by Acquired Acquired by Acquired by Acquired by Follow-On Offering Modem Media, Inc. Valassis Communications Inc Performics, Inc. ARAG Group Carlson Marketing Group Alliance Data Systems, Inc. Advisor Advisor Advisor Advisor Co-Manager Advisor Advisor April 2011 48
  • 49. Gridley & Company LLC 10 East 53rd Street, 24th Floor New York, NY 10022 212.400.9720 tel 212.400.9717 fax Twitter: @gridleyco www.gridleyco.com April 2011 49