2. Outline
• Background Information
• Previous Research
• Author’s Aims
• The Basic Ingredients
• Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria
• Methods
• Limitations of the Study
• Take Home Messages
• Applications
• References
3. Terminology
• VO2MAX: The maximum amount
of oxygen used per minute
during prolonged high intensity
exercise
• Efficient: achieving maximum
productivity with minimum
wasted effort or expense
• Economical: Synonym for
efficient
• Steady State: A state obtained in
moderate muscular exercise
when the removal of lactic acid
by oxidation keeps pace with its
production.
4. Background
• Running performance depends on a complex interplay of
factors
• 1. A high cardiac output and a high rate of oxygen delivery to
working muscles
• 2.The ability to sustain a high percentage of VO2MAX for long
periods of time
• 3. The ability to move efficiently
• VO2MAX and fractional utilization of VO2MAX are widely
studied determinants of running performance
• Unless VO2MAX is >70 mL/min/kg it is almost impossible to
achieve world class running performances
5. Background
• Established World Class Runners
• Expected average of 75-80 mL/min/kg
• Percentage VO2MAX that can be sustained for slightly >2 hours is
approximately 80-90% for the ≈ 28 minutes (Marathon) and 90-95%
(10 km)
6. Primary Questions
• 1. What is the range in
running economy across
the range of serious
runners?
• 2. Are the differences in
running economy based
on anatomical differences?
• 3. Can running economy
be improved?
7. Differences in Running Economy
• Measured by running at progressively
increasing stages of 4-10 min
duration.
• Running intensity is kept below the
ventilatory threshold.
• Reference treadmill runs in the lab
were done either on a flat treadmill, or
a treadmill with a 1% gradient
• In an ideal world, such runs would be
performed outdoors to fully account
for wind resistance, the characteristics
of the running surface & the minor
undulations present on even level
outdoor terrain.
8. Expression of Running Economy
Can be made in several ways:
• To interpolate (or extrapolate)
the VO2 to a common running
velocity (commonly 268 m.min-1
or 4.47 m.s-1)
• Differences in VO2MAX can be
accentuated if the aerobic
requirement of running is
expressed as VO2/kg-0.75
• An alternative method of
expressing running economy is
in terms of the VO2 required to
run 1km.
10. Anatomical Basis of Differences in
Running Economy
• Distance runners are generally small
people
• African runners who dominate distance
running are often even smaller by such
standards
• Observed to have very thin lower legs,
which is a possible contributor to their
excellent running economy
• Suggested that running economy is
related to body dimensions generally
and is not a uniquely ‘African’ element
• Extraordinary running economy may be
a characteristic of small people generally
and specifically small people with thin
lower legs
11. Can Running Economy be Improved?
• Very few studies of strategies
that might improve running
economy have been done
• Interventions involving strength
and/or plyometric training,
altitude exposure and training in
the heat have been reviewed
with regards to improve running
economy
• Altitude exposure has shown
mixed results. Suggested simple
exposure will improve running
economy.
12. Can Running Economy be Improved?
• Reported by Billat et al that
running economy improved
secondary to adding relatively
HI training in addition to
baseline running
• However, further studies have
shown that running economy
improved subsequent to the
addition of HI interval training to
baseline mileage
13. Final Stretch
• Running economy is clearly
important to running performance
• Considerable range of running
economy, even amongst well
trained runners
• Tendency for East African Runners
to be more economical
• Evidence suggests that running
economy improves with the addition
of HI interval training to baseline
mileage
• Suggested that future improvement
in running performance will depend
on improved economy
14. References
• 1. Joyner MJ. Modeling optimal marathon
perfonnance on the basis of physiological factors. J
Appl Physiol 1991; 71: 683-7
• 2. Pollock ML. Submaximal and maximal working
capacity of elite distance runners: cardiorespiratory
aspects. Ann N Y AcadSci 1976; 301: 310-22
• 3. Costill DL, Thomason H, Roberts E. Fractional
utilization of the aerobic capacity during distance
running. Med Sci Sports
• 1973; 5: 248-52
4. Conley DL, Krahenbuhl GS, Burkett LN. Training
for aerobic
• capacity and running economy. Phys Sportsmed
1981; 9: 107-15
•
• 5. Lucia A, Esteve-Lanao J, Olivan J, et al.
Physiological charac- teristics of the best Eritrean
runners: exceptional running econ- omy. Appl
Physiol Nutr Metab 2006; 31: 530-40
• 6. Saunders PU, Pyne DB, Telford RD, et al. Factors
affecting running economy in trained distance
runners. Sports Med 2004; 34: 465-85
• 7. Saltin B, Larsen H, Terrados N, et al. Aerobic
exercise capacity at sea level and at altitude in
Kenyan boys, junior and senior runners compared
to Scandinavian runners. Scand J Med Sci Sports
1995; 5: 209-21
• 8. Lucia A, Hoyos J, Perez M, et al. Inverse
relationship between V02max and
economy/efficiency in world-class cyclists. Med Sci
Sports Exerc 2002; 34: 2079-84
• 9. Royer TD, Martin PE. Manipulations of leg mass
and moment of inertia: effects on energy cost of
walking. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2005; 37: 649-56
• 10. Billat VL, Flechet B, Petit B, et al. Interval
training at V02max: effects on aerobic performance
and overtraining markers. Med Sci Sports Exerc
1999; 31: 156-63
Notas do Editor
VO2MAX is not a good predictor of performance in an elite group of athletes. May be used as a broad predictor in a broad group of individuals.
Oxidations is loss of electrons
Leads to a large capacity for aerobic adenosine triphosphate regeneration (i.e. high maximal oxygen uptake [VO2MAX])
Known as fractional utilization of VO2MAX
Known as running economy – the main focus of the paper
Running is done long enough to reach a physiological steady state. What is this??
Physiological steady state - A state obtained in moderate muscular exercise when the removal of lactic acid by oxidation keeps pace with its production.
Firstly, What is the ventilatory threshold?
- Ventilatory Threshold – Point during exercise training at which pulmonary ventilation becomes disproportionately high with respect to oxygen consumption; believed to reflect onset of anaerobiosis and lactate accumulation.
- Why is intensity kept below this threshold? Because once past this intensity, the slow component of O2 uptake (VO2) dictates that steady state conditions are unlikely to be achieved.
1% gradient was used to correct for the wind resistance that would be encountered during over-ground running.
What is interpolation and extrapolation?
Interpolate: insert (something of a different nature) into something else
Extrapolate: extend the application of (a method or conclusion) to an unknown situation by assuming that existing trends will continue or similar methods will be applicable
6 minutes/mile or 3minutes 44 seconds per km.
A Conceptually more attractive approach primarily used in Scandinavia
Representative values, allowing for the differences in velocity amongst different groups (and assuming a 1% grade on the treadmill belt) are presented in table II and in figure
2. If data can be confirmed then it would suggest that the primary reason that runners with an East African origin are economical is because of their small size
4. May be seen as common sense, as we know that adding weight at the end of a long lever (as in running shoes, or specifically a greater calf girth) is important to the energy cost of ambulation
Ambulate definition: To move from place to place. i.e. walk
1. Surprising considering the importance of running economy to running performance
2. ?What is Plyometric training: exercise involving repeated rapid stretching and contracting of muscles (as by jumping and rebounding) to increase muscle power.
- described in the article as working either by augmenting the stretch/ shortening characteristics of the muscle or by in- creasing the stiffness of the muscle-tendon system.
?How might this help? Helps to make muscle recruitment more efficient. i.e. “Increasing the rate at which muscles can produce force helps improve how oxygen is used to maintain any given speed. It’s really about exploiting the elastic properties of muscles and tendons and how they utilize elastic energy.” The better the muscles are at producing force against the ground quickly, the less time you spend on the ground.
3. Unclear as to how this process is mediated
1. Benefits were seen when such training was performed twice weekly, however such benefits were lost when HI training was performed too often
2. No clear evidence for improvement of running economy with HI interval training – argued that already well trained athletes with little possibility for additional adaptation of VO2MAX, the only way to make a difficult task easier (e.g. running 1000m at VO2MAX) is through running economy
3. Tendency - This may be due to function of small size and small lower limbs as of ‘African’ origin
4. Training Factors – Plyometric training, altitude and heat exposure is believed to contribute to improved running economy. “How so” is currently unclear
5. Why – Because high level athletes already have, either through training or selection, high values for VO2MAX and the ability to sustain VO2MAX